
The Dismemberment Plan’s Emergency & I catapulted them to a new level, with its tales of post-college, pre-millennial tension. It found instant acclaim, despite their brief misadventure with Interscope Records ending prior to its release. It is a record a major label wouldn’t have known what to do with, anyway. The lone Interscope release from the D-Plan had “The Ice of Boston” and an early version of “Spider in the Snow”, two of the band’s signature tracks. Interscope couldn’t figure out what to do with it, even in an age when plenty of lesser, glib “novelty” tracks found mainstream acceptance. No matter. Emergency & I was released and found its people.
Two years later, anticipation was high for Change, which was released a few weeks after the September 11 attacks. The record already has a more somber tone, but with the Dismemberment Plan being a Washington, DC band, these 11 tracks hit differently in light of events no one could have predicted. “Pay for the Piano”, with its insistence that we find a way to respect everyone, seemed particularly relevant then and still does.
Throughout Change, the album emphasizes rhythm. Many of the songs are anchored by head-nodding beats from Joe Easley, and his work on “Other Side” is simply staggering. The Dismemberment Plan never made any bones about their affinity for pop, and it’s unsurprising to hear them embrace hip-hop drums. In an alternate universe, the Dismemberment Plan are the house band for the end.
They included a chilling cover of Jennifer Paige’s 1990s hit “Crush” on a split with the late, lamented Juno, and they played Chappell Roan’s “Pink Pony Club” at the 2024 Best Friends Forever festival. Fans are always dancing at their shows, despite Morrison calling them out for “Doing the Standing Still” on their second album, Is Terrified. Still, the rhythmic quality of these songs is less for dancing than for locking into a groove.
Opener “Sentimental Man” instantly establishes a more subdued sound, as bassist Eric Axelson and Easley lead an instantly memorable hook. When Travis Morrison enters, it’s that same high vocal that kicks off Emergency & I opener “A Life of Possibilities”, but instead of imploring forward motion as he does on that track, here he proclaims, “There’s no heaven, and there’s no hell / No limbo in between / I think it’s all a lie.” The stakes are different now.
From there, the character explains his philosophy. Instead of replicating that terrible conversation with an atheist at a party that we have all had countless times, he’s more accepting that others might not agree or understand how he can be certain, content to keep it real. It never breaks into a bigger moment like “A Life of Possibilities” does, and that, in a way, is the answer. It’s not resignation, but it is acceptance. That titular change runs through these songs, written in the aftermath of Morrison’s father’s passing.
“Face of the Earth” recalls a brief romance and is reportedly inspired by an interview Morrison saw with Michael Jordan, where he told a story about a woman he had just started dating being pulled under a riptide and drowning. In Morrison’s version, the relationship is nothing special: “As kisses go / It wasn’t anything out of the ordinary.” The relationship exists in a space where he should be a little upset, but it’s not the love of his life. He tries to contact some people, but no one answers. How much is he supposed to do? How long is he supposed to grieve? “It’s not like we were married / It was three or four months.”
It’s an intriguing premise for a song. Musically, it slows the propulsion of “Sentimental Man” to a crawl and adds bursts of noise as Morrison watches his unnamed lover float away, “Limbs flailing like an unloved marionette.” While the track has its source, it’s easy to project it onto one’s own missed or short-lived connections.
“Superpowers” is another lyrically fascinating track, with the narrator recounting the mundane events he’s witnessed through his abilities. Morrison’s purposefully flattened delivery of events like “The rich risk[ing] it all for fifteen minutes in a Heathrow bathroom” and other provocative images before declaring, “I guess you could call them superpowers / But no one is going to save the world with what I’ve got.” The song’s extended instrumental break, which runs until the end, shows how locked in the bandmates are, and it is a highlight of the record.
Later, Morrison takes on the titular role in “Time Bomb”, and it’s a chilling track, especially given the environment into which it was released. Truth be told, the song had been around for a while by the time it appeared on the Dismemberment Plan’s Change, making its way into setlists on the Emergency & I dates. I can recall it popping up at those shows toward the end of the set. Morrison taking on these abilities and doing nothing of note with them, and him later embodying an explosive convey the mindset on Change brilliantly. You can be a detached observer, or you can act.
Where tracks like “I Love a Magician” and “Girl O’Clock” on Emergency & I have whimsy, the themes and characters on Change follow the vein of the more somber tracks like “The City” and “Spider in the Snow”. This is a more resigned record, dealing with ideas that are more or less decided rather than the Life of Possibilities. “Come Home” imparts some wisdom (“You’re either wrong or right and life will go on, whatever you choose” and “Anger’s all right / Bitterness no”) via Morrison’s deceased father. Life is going on whether you want it to or not, and you will need to get used to being wrong sometimes. You will get through it.
A suite of songs seems to address a lost connection in the back half of Change, and three of them are highlights. “Automatic” is spare and cutting, with Morrison singing lines like “Once again the politics of common sense / You do and I don’t” with a detached resignation. From there, “Following Through” starts with a mournful, catchy riff and features Morrison lamenting a lost connection with the gutting “I get up at 5 am / I so don’t need these dreams anymore that I used to have” before finding a way forward.
The final stretch of Change is the aforementioned “Time Bomb”, an uncharacteristically ferocious song that provides the record’s climax, followed by the drum-and-bass track “The Other Side”. The drums sound programmed, but they aren’t. Easley is just that great. It’s a kitchen sink track, throwing out bitter missives about the lows of relationships, and one of the key songs from the D-Plan. In a Spin interview, Morrison said the song was borne of a desire to emulate an obscure local band called Lake Trout’s song “Little Things in Different Places”.
“The Other Side” caps the introspection and sets up the closer, “Ellen and Ben”, which tells a tale that ties up the themes of Change. The song is based on real people Morrison knew. By ending on this uncertainty and a call to stay in touch, Morrison shows how people evolve and how love can sour even as people keep growing. Ellen and Ben break up loudly at a wedding and never see each other again. The best he can offer is an analysis that Ellen and Ben were madly in love, but couldn’t even stay friends when it ended and an assurance that he’s keeping his eyes on the prize. It’s a fitting end to a record steeped in resignation in the face of uncertainty.
As someone who was trudging through the same phases of life that the Dismemberment Plan’s Emergency & I and Change covered, it was easy to see them as companions. Emergency & I is a graduation gift of sorts, a point of entry into the real world. Change is a two-year check-in, where life has gotten far less exciting and far more exhausting, but it’s still too early to give in to hopelessness. When Change arrived, I was a raw nerve over a short-lived romance. It isn’t much in the grand scheme of things, but it was there, and it was painful at the time.
Some lines in the resignation of these tracks speak to an inner peace, while others speak to a restlessness that will likely never be settled. Take the joys, however fleeting, and savor them before the next wave of concerns in this Life of Possibilities emerges. Hang with your nephew and keep your eyes on the prize.
