
“Everybody knows that the naked man and woman are just a shining artifact of the past,” the 53-year-old trickster disguised as a prophet Leonard Cohen crooned, his mordant wit jabbing fate in the ribs. With the title Mammoth, the London-born, Paris-based singer-songwriter Flora Hibberd suggests a similar idea: extinction. While Cohen found gallows humor in our demise, Hibberd is preoccupied with listening to the dead, an eternal tongue refusing to be aphonic. This is why Hibberd has her ear to the ground, or, rather, the sky.
Therefore, on her sophomore album, Mammoth, Hibberd acts as an antenna, picking up signals from the ether. Dead voices gather and speak, encircling her like a storm. A threshold crossed and recrossed as if eternity were a bridge. Starting as a folk artist, Hibberd swallowed Cohen’s songbook and hurled it back out with fire, as in the titular track of her first EP, The Absentee (2019).
With youthful alacrity, when time is non-negotiable, Hibberd is more or less bellowing: “Hey, Cohen, my body is burning with creativity, like Joan of Arc.” Hibberd passed on a secret language, a medley of ancient tongues, firing eternal truths like bullets. Undoubtedly, Hibberd is copiously talented, with a stentorian voice, part Cate Le Bon, part chanteuse, that fills the hollow night with poignant depth.
Swirl, Hibberd’s 2025 debut album, is, arguably, a departure from her earlier folk leanings. Within a bedrock of warm analog production, songs fall from Hibberd’s prophetic mind. They are the language of dreams, symbols of kismet, an all-seeing eye upon a future slipping into the past. Like Swirl, Mammoth contains stately arrangements and lush instrumentation, including curlicue pedal steels and reverb-laden electric guitars.
Whereas the folk-pop Swirl exudes sophistication, the synth-driven Mammoth is expansive and fantastical; you could be watching a Mummers’ play with Keats and Shelley. Mammoth is built upon a jittery art-pop aesthetic that threatens to overwhelm the nimble-footed compositions. Other new additions come by the way of brass and woodwinds. Some things remain the same, though: Hibberd is preoccupied with ghosts, higher stations, God, and the God above that. Also, Hibberd’s mystery, coupled with her wont to abstraction, is still at the forefront.
Hibberd understands creation involves smoke and mirrors: beautiful illusions with ugly consequences. Yes, being an artist calls for performance, which is exactly what Hibberd does. She wears masks and plays roles, escapes and becomes herself—transfiguration. Hibberd understands that an image can elicit responses and endless interpretations—pop is hermeneutics, after all. “Everyone knows it’s pretend,” Hibberd intones in “Ache”, throwing the point in your face like cold water.
The opener, “Bowling Ball”, begins with shimmering, Rocco strings as if this were the start of Arcade Fire‘s The Suburbs, until a bouncy rhythm section enters, including circular acoustic guitar fingerpicking. The narrator addresses the listener as if it were the start of a theater show, coming full circle with “Ticket”, the last track on Swirl. “I shuffle through the faces I was given / I don’t find myself grateful,” Hibberd laconically sings.
The up-tempo “Silent Movie Baby” is about tuning into a higher station, where the narrator aligns ghosts, complemented by an infectious flute, rumbling bass, and punchy tom-toms. The next two tracks slow the album to a somnolent pace and offer little: Sufjan Stevens-featured “Perfect Ripple” and the piano ballad “Deltaplane”. The LP picks up again with “Mythic Figure”, which, with the piano and backing vocals, could be Aldous Harding, if the New Zealander were preoccupied with God rather than John Cale eating rice (I prefer to watch the Welsh musician, Cale, eat cawl).
With Mammoth, Hibberd has ventured down a not-so-uncommon indie pop road. While this stylistic change will appeal to a larger audience, it occasionally dilutes her beguiling charm and, in the case of “Ache”, becomes a simulacrum of her aesthetic.
That said, the rest of the sprightly quasi-pop numbers are not formulaic, as the title track “Mammoth” proves with its anthemic chorus, which lifts you out of the mire of existence and into the absolute, blasted by a sun-scorched trombone. Throughout, Victor Claass, Hibberd’s longtime collaborator, plays an enchanting electric-guitar riff, producing a quick succession of notes right after the words “night herd moves”. It is as if he is unlocking a door to a secret passage, or reaching inside the instrument to release the music within like a flock of birds.
Another highlight of Mammoth is “Dew Pond”, a muffled prayer that seems to go nowhere and everywhere. Continuing the motif of artifice, the imagery of a dew pond—a human-made pond—serves as a metaphor for creativity’s deceptiveness. Yet that isn’t what draws you into the number; rather, it is Flora Hibberd’s unmistakable voice. For instance, she dramatizes a brute-force quiver by dragging each word like a body through mud, toying with and defying syllables to signify absence.
The title, “Shelley”, is most likely named after the Romantic poet, Percy Bysshe Shelley, a muse-like figure whom the narrator invokes, as if calling upon one of the nine Muses on Mount Olympus. The melody discreetly climbs over you like a lover in the morning, and the weeping pedal steel echoes Purple Mountains’ self-titled album.
“Hares on the Mountain” is an English traditional folk song, covered by Shirley Collins, recorded with Davy Graham. Hibberd brings out the feyness of the ballad, with poise and grace, evincing what was hidden all along, or hidden in plain sight, on Mammoth: folk. It is as if a new narrative suddenly emerges from this cover to rewrite the album. Although Mammoth is infused with pulsive art-pop, you can still feel the spirits of Barbara Allen and the Cuckoo Bird; the surreal language is rooted in the folk tradition.
In whatever genre, Hibberd retains folk practices, as Bob Dylan kept to his folk roots when he went electric. Similarly to the shape-shifting musician, Hibberd inhabits different personae and makes you believe in the song, or the song believes in you. Put differently, Hibberd turns the track around to face you like a mirror.
With Mammoth, eternity leads Flora Hibberd by the hand to moments of illumination, where something that didn’t exist appears as if it always has. Following in the footsteps of great artists, Hibberd is preoccupied with reality and reverie, the inadequacy of language, the roles of masks, and the plurality of the Self. It will take a lifetime to decipher—like a code hidden in Ice Age art—but we’ll hear from Hibberd again somewhere in the ether.
