How Much Will You Pay for Some Christian Comfort? 'Thieves in the Temple'

Thieves in the Temple offers a critique of the modern-day 'feel good' Christian church in America that rings true even as it feels incomplete.

Thieves in the Temple: The Christian Church and the Selling of the American Soul

Publisher: Basic
Length: 240 pages
Author: G. Jeffrey MacDonald
Price: $16.99
Format: Paperback
Publication date: 2013-05
"Faith has become a consumer commodity in America. People shop for congregations that make them feel comfortable rather than spiritually challenged. They steer clear of formal commitments to Christian communities. They flee when they are not quickly gratified or when they encounter interpersonal problems. Changing churches has become as routine as changing jobs."

-- G. Jeffrey MacDonald

Originally released in 2010 and now out in paperback form with a new epilogue, G. Jeffrey MacDonald’s Thieves in the Temple offers a critique of the Christian church in America that rings true even as it feels incomplete. MacDonald’s view is that a consumer-oriented mindset has come to infect wide swaths of American Protestantism, which has given rise to churches both liberal and conservative, white and black, big and small, that emphasize entertainment and comfort rather than Christ-like virtues such as sacrifice and self-denial. In short, Christian life has become easy.

How has this happened? MacDonald, himself an ordained minister as well as a journalist, argues from experience. With deep pastoral concern, he contends that because Americans are more willing than ever to switch their houses of worship, churches are under increasing pressure to make fewer and fewer demands of their parishioners (this at a time when denominations across the board are hemorrhaging members). The thinking goes that emotional uplift and affirmation will help retain "customers" while the call to live out "challenging forms of discipleship" may only drive them away.

However, as MacDonald sees it, the church’s mission is not to boost membership rolls but to change hearts and save souls, and the therapeutic, frills-heavy packaging that the Christian message so often comes in these days is a threat to the latter. On all of these points, MacDonald’s analysis is convincing, and yet there are certain omissions that seem glaring.

In the first half of Thieves in the Temple, MacDonald pinpoints many of the ways in which the American church has violated its true calling. The list is lengthy, especially with regard to the influx of "spiritually flavored entertainment" into church life. On the more frivolous end of the spectrum, there are activities like Christian comedy shows, product giveaways, and church movie outings. MacDonald rightly wonders what the connection is between events such as these and following the example of Christ.

He spends far more time, however, examining how the push for ease and entertainment has gutted very significant church traditions of their meaning. Baptism and communion no longer entail sacred commitments. Weddings have become little more than celebrations of the newly-weds-to-be. And overseas missions could easily be mistaken for adventurous getaways. According to MacDonald, all of this demonstrates that "comfort has become a central goal of worship".

Elsewhere, he takes the church to task for its "therapeutic function" and its failure to develop the kind of moral character among believers that sets them apart from the rest of society. To buttress this second point, he cites a study from 2009 which showed that sizable majorities of various Christian subgroups, like white evangelicals and mainline Protestants, don’t flat-out reject the use of torture. It’s a truly scandalous finding.

As stinging as MacDonald’s overall critique is, though, a crucial piece is missing: what about the messages coming from the pulpit every Sunday? Aren't sermons -- and, crucially, the doctrine they contain -- the centerpiece of a worship service, informing everything else that takes place? Aren’t they perhaps the most important window into how a church understands its mission? It seems to follow that if a church's handling of the Christian message is amiss, everything else will be, too. As a minister, MacDonald recognizes this. He writes, "Pastors need to be sure they’re not only proclaiming orthodox doctrine, but are also spelling out its broad requirements for the Christian life."

If that's his stance, though, then why would he by and large ignore sermons, where doctrine and its day-to-day implications should be found in abundance? The closest he comes to tackling the formal, systematic presentation of "the Gospel" within American Protestantism is found at the beginning of Thieves in the Temple, when he chides prosperity preachers for their foul mangling of Christ’s words. Beyond that, there's little else. One would think that if MacDonald was willing to spill ink over, say, the theology of tithing and certain burial practices, he would also see fit to address this area in some detail. Doctrine is, after all, the bedrock of church life.

In part two of Thieves in the Temple, MacDonald profiles three churches and one college, all in the Minneapolis/St. Paul metro area, that in his opinion have pushed back against the tide of "cheap grace" (to use the words of Dietrich Bonhoffer). The common thread among these examples is a commitment to the idea that "spiritual growth is supposed to be difficult and uncomfortable at times." For example, MacDonald meets with a woman who, inspired by her church's message of sacrificial love, walked away from a cushy suburban lifestyle and moved to the inner city so she could serve a community in need. He also details how people in small group settings at one church have held each other accountable in ways that bear fruit.

According to MacDonald, one of the keys to understanding these success stories is to recognize that the effects of the "new religious marketplace" don't have to be negative. Because laypeople are now able to exert influence in such consequential ways, they're uniquely positioned to demand that their church ask more of them. As MacDonald writes, "Few moments in history have offered ordinary people as much opportunity to shape the institution that points to highest things." But whether they will or not on a large scale is another matter, which creates room for skepticism of MacDonald's hopeful perspective.

I don't think it's faint praise to say that Thieves in the Temple is a good book that should have been better. More to the point, it should have been longer. MacDonald is absolutely correct that a Christianity that doesn't make weighty and at times painful demands of its followers is an empty Christianity. But in a longer version of the book, he might have used more space to describe how American Protestantism arrived at this strange and uncertain moment. His thumbnail sketch of recent church history has obvious limitations. (The same problem hampered Ross Douthat's Bad Religion.) And in a longer version, he might have focused more on the health of the Gospel message within the American church.

What is it about the preaching of Christian doctrine across the sweep of Protestant denominations that has allowed for this spiritual decay to set in? It's a question I returned to time and again while reading Thieves in the Temple.





The Kinks and Their Bad-Mannered English Decency

Mark Doyles biography of the Kinks might complement a seminar in British culture. Its tone and research prove its intent to articulate social critique through music for the masses.


ONO Confronts American Racial Oppression with the Incendiary 'Red Summer'

Decades after their initial formation, legendary experimentalists ONO have made an album that's topical, vital, uncomfortable, and cathartic. Red Summer is an essential documentation of the ugliness and oppression of the United States.


Silent Women Filmmakers No Longer So Silent: Alice Guy Blaché and Julia Crawford Ivers

The works of silent filmmakers Alice Guy Blaché and Julia Crawford Ivers were at risk of being forever lost. Kino Lorber offers their works on Blu-Ray. Three cheers for film historians and film restoration.


Rush's 'Permanent Waves' Endures with Faultless Commercial Complexity

Forty years later, Rush's ability to strike a nearly perfect balance between mainstream invitingness and exclusory complexity is even more evident and remarkable. The progressive rock classic, Permanent Waves, is celebrating its 40th anniversary.


Drum Machines? Samples? Brendan Benson Gets Contemporary with 'Dear Life'

Powerpop overlord and part-time Raconteur, Brendan Benson, grafts hip-hop beats to guitar pop on his seventh solo album, Dear Life.


'Sell You Everything' Brings to Light Buzzcocks '1991 Demo LP' That Passed Under-the-Radar

Cherry Red Records' new box-set issued in memory of Pete Shelley gathers together the entire post-reunion output of the legendary Buzzcocks. Across the next week, PopMatters explores the set album-by-album. First up is The 1991 Demo LP.


10 Key Tracks From the British Synthpop Boom of 1980

It's 40 years since the first explosion of electronic songs revitalized the UK charts with futuristic subject matter, DIY aesthetics, and occasionally pompous lyrics. To celebrate, here's a chronological list of those Moog-infused tracks of 1980 that had the biggest impact.

Reading Pandemics

Poe, Pandemic, and Underlying Conditions

To read Edgar Allan Poe in the time of pandemic, we need to appreciate a very different aspect of his perspective—not that of a mimetic artist but of the political economist.


'Yours, Jean' Is a Perfect Mixture of Tragedy, Repressed Desire, and Poor Impulse Control

Lee Martin's Yours, Jean is a perfectly balanced and heartbreaking mix of true crime narrative and literary fiction.


The 60 Best Albums of 2007

From tech house to Radiohead and Americana to indie and everything in between, the 60 best albums of 2007 included many of the 2000s' best albums.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Solitude Stands in the Window: Thoreau's 'Walden'

Henry David Thoreau's Walden as a 19th century model for 21st century COVID-19 quarantine.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Will COVID-19 Kill Movie Theaters?

Streaming services and large TV screens have really hurt movie theaters and now the coronavirus pandemic has shuttered multiplexes and arthouses. The author of The Perils of Moviegoing in America, however, is optimistic.

Gary D. Rhodes, Ph.D
Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.