The Translators of 'Thousand and One Nights' Were Unquestionably Thieves

Marvellous Thieves notes that each interpreter's acts of plagiarism, theft, and recreation are nearly as interesting as the tales themselves.

Marvellous Thieves: Secret Authors of the Arabian Nights

Publisher: Harvard University Press
Length: 384 pages
Author: Paulo Lemos Horta
Price: $29.95
Format: Hardcover
Publication date: 2017-01

In a way, Richard Burton -- the subject of the last chapter of Horta's Marvellous Thieves -- encapsulates all that preceded him throughout the book. By the end, Burton came to embody -- partly as a result of the Thousand and One Nights’ translational history and partly because of how Paulo Lemos Horta has structured his book -- the natural conclusion of each of the included translators' accumulated endeavors.

Beginning with Antoine Galland in the early 18th century, the men who translated the Thousand and One Nights each, in their own way, sought to merge themselves in some way with the content of the narrative. From the connections Horta draws between Galland's orphan tales and Hanna Diyab and Paul Lucas's travels, to Edward Williams Lane's thorough incorporation of his Modern Egyptians ethnography with his Thousand and One Nights translation. It was Burton, though, by casting himself quite literally as a fictional Arab (then Persian) personality Mirza Abdullah, who brought about the natural evolution of the earlier men's acts of translation and self-creation.

Near the beginning of Marvellous Thieves, Horta observes that: "Common elements within the travelogues of Lucas and the memoir of Diyab suggest that the two men were exchanging stories ... and both authors reveal an attraction to fabulous tales that mirror features of the orphan tales" (i.e., the tales Antoine Galland included in his translation, told to him by Diyab in Lucas's Paris apartment). This merging of the lives of the translators (or in this case, the deliverer of some of the orphan tales) and the exoticized world of the Thousand and One Nights is a recurring theme in Horta's recounting of the men's lives.

Although Horta's presentation of Diyab's personal adventures as possible source for the content of the "orphan tales" sometimes borders on Oxfordian tenuousness, there's no mistake that Diyab's life must have flavored the stories he recounted to Galland in Lucas's apartment. Once again, as the book progresses, it is the translators themselves who seek to live out the exotic adventures Galland only heard of from Diyab. By the book's end, Burton has even adopted Abdullah's personality to permit him to act out the experience most unique to the Islamic world: the hajj. Here it's clear that Marvellous Thieves has progressed far beyond Edward Williams Lane's now-passé tale of witnessing ink-stained divination.

Connected to their longing to partake in the imagined world of the Thousand and One Nights, another shared characteristic of many of the translators Horta discusses is the effort each man undertook to try and present himself as the singularly qualified figure to translate these stories, often by trying to subtly (or not-so-subtly) dismiss their predecessors' efforts, no matter how each was indebted to the others. Each took different routes to try to demonstrate that he understood "the Arab" (or "the Indian" or "the Persian", wherever each imagined the stories originated) best and therefore was best situated to translate the Thousand and One Nights for readers back home. This element figures particularly in the chapters on Lane and Henry Torrens -- each man aware of their limits of their own ability and version. Yet Horta casts each man sympathetically despite fertile ground to dismiss many as arrogantly Orientalist (a term Horta retrieves from being only an academic pejorative). Instead, he finds within their rivalries and misunderstandings, a history of several men each with a natural combination of selfish and thoughtful motives.

Of Burton himself, perhaps one of the least sympathetic translators of Thousand and One Nights, Horta writes: "Burton's 'Terminal Essay' to the Arabian Nights reflects his own understanding of the potential that lay within the story collection to provide a disruptive education in alternative beliefs and social practices." In fact, the role that Thousand and One Nights and its various translations played in educational (or overall colonial) policy is another theme Horta manages to pack succinctly into each account. In the chapter on Torrens (one of the India-situated translators), Horta emphasizes the often-ignored translator's contributions: "Torrens's translation ... remained unfinished, but it is the invisible thread that weaves through the history of the Arabian Nights in English." It was Torrens, in fact, who saw the value of preserving the cultural reservoir of colonial cultures not only for the cultural value but as wise policy, and Torrens emerges from Horta's account as the most empathetic character.

The translators Horta recounts were unquestionably thieves -- of each other, of their sources and interlocutors, of their own personal encounters in Arab, Persian, and Indian cities they visited. But Horta makes a persuasive case that each man's acts of plagiarism, theft, recreation, and simple fabrication are nearly as interesting stories as the ones they were toiling to bring to Western readers. Each man, whether Antoine Galland and Hanna Diyab or Richard Burton, was seeking to make his mark upon the world and preserve literature. There are numerous books recounting the problematic legacy of colonial translators, ethnographers, or simple civil servants like Torrens, but that book is not Marvellous Thieves and Horta has given readers a highly enjoyable account of the story behind the Thousand and One Nights.





'Everything's Gonna Be Okay' Is  Better Than Okay

The first season of Freeform's Everything's Gonna Be Okay is a funny, big-hearted love letter to family.


Jordan Rakei Breathes New Life Into Soul Music

Jordan Rakei is a restless artistic spirit who brings R&B, jazz, hip-hop, and pop craft into his sumptuous, warm music. Rakei discusses his latest album and new music he's working on that will sound completely different from everything he's done so far.


Country Music's John Anderson Counts the 'Years'

John Anderson, who continues to possess one of country music's all-time great voices, contemplates life, love, mortality, and resilience on Years.


Rory Block's 'Prove It on Me' Pays Tribute to Women's Blues

The songs on Rory Block's Prove It on Me express the strength of female artists despite their circumstances as second class citizens in both the musical world and larger American society.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 3, Echo & the Bunnymen to Lizzy Mercier Descloux

This week we are celebrating the best post-punk albums of all-time and today we have part three with Echo & the Bunnymen, Cabaret Voltaire, Pere Ubu and more.


Wendy Carlos: Musical Pioneer, Reluctant Icon

Amanda Sewell's vastly informative new biography on musical trailblazer Wendy Carlos is both reverent and honest.


British Folk Duo Orpine Share Blissful New Song "Two Rivers" (premiere)

Orpine's "Two Rivers" is a gently undulating, understated folk song that provides a welcome reminder of the enduring majesty of nature.


Blesson Roy Gets "In Tune With the Moon" (premiere)

Terry Borden was a member of slowcore pioneers Idaho and a member of Pete Yorn's band. Now he readies the debut of Blesson Roy and shares "In Tune With the Moon".


In 'Wandering Dixie', Discovering the Jewish South Is Part of Discovering Self

Sue Eisenfeld's Wandering Dixie is not only a collection of dispatches from the lost Jewish South but also a journey of self-discovery.


Bill Withers and the Curse of the Black Genius

"Lean on Me" singer-songwriter Bill Withers was the voice of morality in an industry without honor. It's amazing he lasted this long.


Jeff Baena Explores the Intensity of Mental Illness in His Mystery, 'Horse Girl'

Co-writer and star Alison Brie's unreliable narrator in Jeff Baena's Horse Girl makes for a compelling story about spiraling into mental illness.


Pokey LaFarge Hits 'Rock Bottom' on His Way Up

Americana's Pokey LaFarge performs music in front of an audience as a way of conquering his personal demons on Rock Bottom.


Joni Mitchell's 'Shine' Is More Timely and Apt Than Ever

Joni Mitchell's 2007 eco-nightmare opus, Shine is more timely and apt than ever, and it's out on vinyl for the first time.


'Live at Carnegie Hall' Captures Bill Withers at His Grittiest and Most Introspective

Bill Withers' Live at Carnegie Hall manages to feel both exceptionally funky and like a new level of grown-up pop music for its time.


Dual Identities and the Iranian Diaspora: Sepehr Debuts 'Shaytoon'

Electronic producer Sepehr discusses his debut album releasing Friday, sparing no detail on life in the Iranian diaspora, the experiences of being raised by ABBA-loving Persian rug traders, and the illegal music stores that still litter modern Iran.


From the Enterprise to the Discovery: The Decline and Fall of Utopian Technology and the Liberal Dream

The technology and liberalism of recent series such as Star Trek: Discovery, Star Trek: Picard, and the latest Doctor Who series have more in common with Harry Potter's childish wand-waving than Gene Roddenberry's original techno-utopian dream.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 2, The B-52's to Magazine

This week we are celebrating the best post-punk albums of all-time and today we have part two with the Cure, Mission of Burma, the B-52's and more.


Emily Keener's "Boats" Examines Our Most Treasured Relationships (premiere)

Folk artist Emily Keener's "Boats" offers a warm look back on the road traveled so far—a heartening reflection for our troubled times.


Paul Weller - "Earth Beat" (Singles Going Steady)

Paul Weller's singular modes as a soul man, guitar hero, and techno devotee converge into a blissful jam about hope for the earth on "Earth Beat".


On Point and Click Adventure Games with Creator Joel Staaf Hästö

Point and click adventure games, says Kathy Rain and Whispers of a Machine creator Joel Staaf Hästö, hit a "sweet spot" between puzzles that exercise logical thinking and stories that stimulate emotions.

Collapse Expand Reviews
Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.