Science

Must We Sacrifice the Beasts at the Altars of Our Fierce Gods?

Photo of Harambe by Cincinnati Zoo

Like the Aztecs before us, and despite the sheen of humane treatment, zoos continue to be sites of ritual animal sacrifice.

This past May, zookeepers at the Cincinnati Zoo shot and killed a 17-year-old Western lowland gorilla after a three-year-old boy fell into its enclosure. The incident stirred a debate that, at least initially, circled frenetically around whom to blame. Some commentators had it out for the mother of the child, citing negligence on her part; others, the zoo itself. Shortly thereafter, discussion turned to the wider question of whether it's ethical to keep gorillas in zoos in the first place.

It's no coincidence that defanged, so to speak, representations of animals have proliferated with the rise of industrial democratic societies.
Defenders of zoos argue that they serve a dual purpose: to educate the public and to conserve endangered animal populations. Frans de Waal, a prominent primatologist from Emory University, recently toldNatalie Angier, reporting for the New York Times, that he was a "big fan" of well-designed zoos. "For great apes," he said, "the record is excellent." Gorillas born and raised in captivity are generally healthier and live longer than their counterparts in the wild. Zoos have learned over the past few decades to engineer experiences for the apes that keep them, as far as the experts can tell, entertained.

One trend is to design enclosures that appear natural -- in part, by simulating the apes' native habitats, but also by eliminating obvious indicators that the gorillas are trapped within a cage. The "naturalness" of the enclosure in this case was, at least indirectly, to blame for the little boy's plight. He had squeezed through a gap in the boundary and fallen down an embankment into a ravine within which the gorilla had free rein.

As wild ape populations are further decimated by the relentless creep of civilization (and by casualties of war and illegal animal trade), it's becoming clear that the role zoos might play as instruments of conservation has been vastly overstated. Gorillas bred in captivity are ill-prepared for the rigors of life in the wild. The rate of population decline outside the gilded cages of First World zoos exceeds their capacity to restock.

With the myth of conservation laid bare, we're left with the cold comfort of zoos as vectors for education. Presumably, as we become further ensconced in the manicured landscapes, both suburban and virtual, that swaddle us, an encounter with a gorilla can be a transformative experience that reminds us of our shared kinship -- and the majesty of nature. We must keep up our zoos for the children.

In her article, Angier points out that when "the first apes were exhibited in the West, in the late 18th century, they were seen as trophies, evidence of imperial victory over savagery." The Enlightenment apotheosis of human superiority may have added another layer of rationalization to the subjugation of savage beasts, but the deeper motivation for zoos has always been their political value; that is, what zoos say about their patrons in the face of other people, whether imperial rivals or lesser social classes. The newly minted Western powers were merely picking up where predecessors, such as the Romans, had left off. Zoos embody the dark side of Enlightenment inquisitiveness.

Consider this passage from Bernal Diaz's account of the conquest of Mexico. Here he's describing the court of the Aztec king Montezuma when Hernan Cortez and his army first entered the city of Tenochtitlan in November 1519:

Let us go on to another large house where they kept many idols whom they called their fierce gods, and with them all kinds of beasts of prey, tigers and two sorts of lion, and beasts rather like wolves [...], and foxes and other small animals, all of them carnivores, and most of them bred there. They were fed on deer, fowls, little dogs, and other creatures which they hunt and also on the bodies of the Indians they sacrificed, as I was told.

Since zoos don't actually conserve, nor educate, beyond the most self-serving and trivial ways, even in modern democratic cultures, they constitute a travesty in the old-fashioned sense of the word. One institution is dressed in the guise of another. Like the Aztecs before us, and despite the sheen of humane treatment, zoos continue to be sites of ritual animal sacrifice. What we sacrifice in zoos are other living creatures, both as curiosities and trophies. These sacrifices serve, not the dual purposes of conservation and education, but other more ancient, crueler purposes. First, zoos testify to the majesty of our conquest of the natural world. Second, zoos broadcast abundance amidst a cutthroat world hardened by scarcity.

Evolutionary biology long ago illuminated the continuity between all life forms. We've read that chimpanzees share 98 percent of our DNA. They use tools. They have rich social relations, culture even. Furthermore, our Hominidae cousins have complex inner lives, full of thoughts, memories, and feelings.

But translating the chimpanzee or the orangutan into the familial vernacular of "cousin" betrays our penchant to anthropomorphize animals. Animals have held a potent totemic significance in nearly all cultures across history. Animals are our neighbors, our rivals, our food, and on occasion, even our friends. But portrayals of animals in art and popular culture inevitably say more about us than they do about the creatures we're representing. From Aesop's Fables to Chaucer's The Parliament of Fowls to "Old MacDonald Had a Farm" to Bugs Bunny, representations of animals reinforce our own cloistered preoccupations, or own solipsisms. It's no coincidence that defanged, so to speak, representations of animals have proliferated with the rise of industrial democratic societies. We must work ever harder to pixel over the cognitive dissonance between Babe and the mass incarceration and slaughter of cows, chickens, and pigs for our fast food dining pleasure.

Giving this particular Western lowland gorilla, raised in captivity, a name such as "Harambe", only confirms the solipsism. It's highly likely that Harambe had absolutely no use for the name given him. That the name sounds vaguely African makes it all the more condescending. A benign form of Orientalism.

One of humanism's great unreconciled paradoxes is its take on animals. On the one hand, our discoveries have made it blindingly obvious that we are they. On the other hand, the more we learn about animals as objects of study, the more we realize that other living things are fundamentally unknowable. This is why the zookeepers at the Cincinnati Zoo came to the grim conclusion that, as Harambe poked and thrashed that fragile three-year-old boy around, they had to shoot him dead. They just didn't know what he was thinking, what he would do. The grimmer moral calculus of zoos forces us to articulate, if not in word then in deed, that a human life is worth more than a gorilla's.

We tend to think of animals as discrete entities. They occupy a quasi-category between object and person. With some animals, we have long-standing relationships, relationships we might consider intimate. It's not at all clear whether it was we who domesticated dogs or the other way around. With dogs, unlike gorillas, there's the semblance of an equitable pact, if not pack. But with others, it's all too easy, for reasons obvious (dinner time) and subtle (that pernicious solipsism), to shunt most animals over to the object end of the spectrum.

Nevertheless, an animal is an organism, a complex aggregation of cells tightly coupled to a particular environment. That environment is both social and physical. The subspecies Gorilla gorilla gorilla is known as the Western lowland gorilla for a reason. It's native to the western lowlands of central Africa. The Western lowland gorilla belongs to and belongs in the western lowlands.

Dr. de Waal says enthusiastically that gorillas "like to work on computers". As we amuse ourselves by gawping at them in simulations of their native habitat, we can try to amuse these gorillas with computer games. But a gorilla, a complex organism tightly coupled to an environment, is only the shadow of its authentic self in a zoo. If we project the human value of dignity on our cousins, to grant them their dignity, the least we could do is leave them alone where they are.

To accomplish that, though, we must undertake a monumental reckoning. We must resolve whether to carry on sacrificing all kinds of beasts at the altars of our fierce gods.

Music


Books


Film


Recent
Music

Run the Jewels - "Ooh LA LA" (Singles Going Steady)

Run the Jewels' "Ooh LA LA" may hit with old-school hip-hop swagger, but it also frustratingly affirms misogynistic bro-culture.

Books

New Translation of Balzac's 'Lost Illusions' Captivates

More than just a tale of one man's fall, Balzac's Lost Illusions charts how literature becomes another commodity in a system that demands backroom deals, moral compromise, and connections.

Music

Protomartyr - "Processed by the Boys" (Singles Going Steady)

Protomartyr's "Processed By the Boys" is a gripping spin on reality as we know it, and here, the revolution is being televised.

Music

Go-Go's Bassist Kathy Valentine Is on the "Write" Track After a Rock-Hard Life

The '80s were a wild and crazy time also filled with troubles, heartbreak and disappointment for Go-Go's bass player-guitarist Kathy Valentine, who covers many of those moments in her intriguing dual project that she discusses in this freewheeling interview.

Music

New Brain Trajectory: An Interview With Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree

Two guitarists, Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree make an album largely absent of guitar playing and enter into a bold new phase of their careers. "We want to take this wherever we can and be free of genre restraints," says Lee Ranaldo.

Books

'Trans Power' Is a Celebration of Radical Power and Beauty

Juno Roche's Trans Power discusses trans identity not as a passageway between one of two linear destinations, but as a destination of its own.

Music

Yves Tumor Soars With 'Heaven to a Tortured Mind'

On Heaven to a Tortured Mind, Yves Tumor relishes his shift to microphone caressing rock star. Here he steps out of his sonic chrysalis, dons some shiny black wings and soars.

Music

Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras' tētēma Don't Hit the Mark on 'Necroscape'

tētēma's Necroscape has some highlights and some interesting ambiance, but ultimately it's a catalog of misses for Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras.

Music

M. Ward Offers Comforting Escapism on 'Migration Stories'

Although M. Ward didn't plan the songs on Migration Stories for this pandemic, they're still capable of acting as a balm in these dark hours.

Music

Parsonsfield Add Indie Pop to Their Folk on 'Happy Hour on the Floor'

Happy Hour on the Floor is a considerable departure from Parsonsfield's acclaimed rustic folk sound signaling their indie-pop orientation. Parsonsfield remind their audience to bestow gratitude and practice happiness: a truly welcomed exaltation.

Music

JARV IS... - "House Music All Night Long" (Singles Going Steady)

"House Music All Night Long" is a song our inner, self-isolated freaks can jive to. JARV IS... cleverly captures how dazed and confused some of us may feel over the current pandemic, trapped in our homes.

Music

All Kinds of Time: Adam Schlesinger's Pursuit of Pure, Peerless Pop

Adam Schlesinger was a poet laureate of pure pop music. There was never a melody too bright, a lyrical conceit too playfully dumb, or a vibe full of radiation that he would shy away from. His sudden passing from COVID-19 means one of the brightest stars in the power-pop universe has suddenly dimmed.

Music

Folkie Eliza Gilkyson Turns Up the Heat on '2020'

Eliza Gilkyson aims to inspire the troops of resistance on her superb new album, 2020. The ten songs serve as a rallying cry for the long haul.

Music

Human Impact Hit Home with a Seismic First Album From a Veteran Lineup

On their self-titled debut, Human Impact provide a soundtrack for this dislocated moment where both humanity and nature are crying out for relief.

Music

Monophonics Are an Ardent Blast of True Rock 'n' Soul on 'It's Only Us'

The third time's the charm as Bay Area soul sextet Monophonics release their shiniest record yet in It's Only Us.

Film

'Slay the Dragon' Is a Road Map of the GOP's Methods for Dividing and Conquering American Democracy

If a time traveler from the past wanted to learn how to subvert democracy for a few million bucks, gerrymandering documentary Slay the Dragon would be a superb guide.

Music

Bobby Previte / Jamie Saft / Nels Cline: Music from the Early 21st Century

A power-trio of electric guitar, keyboards, and drums takes on the challenge of free improvisation—but using primarily elements of rock and electronica as strongly as the usual creative music or jazz. The result is focused.

Books

Does Inclusivity Mean That Everyone Does the Same Thing?

What is the meaning of diversity in today's world? Russell Jacoby raises and addresses some pertinent questions in his latest work, On Diversity.

Reviews
Collapse Expand Reviews
Features
Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.