Reviews

New York, New York

Scorsese films Liza Minelli like a '40s musical screen goddess, and she repays him with one of her most relaxed, assured acting performances.


New York, New York

Director: Martin Scorsese
Cast: Robert De Niro, Liza Minnelli, Lionel Stander, Barry Primus
Distributor: MGM
MPAA rating: PG
Subtitle: 30th Anniversary Edition
First date: 2008
US DVD Release Date: 2007-12-04

We have all heard John Kander and Fred Ebb’s title song about a million times, usually crooned by that old smoothie Frank Sinatra. “I want to wake up, in the city that never sleeps…” You know the rest. It’s a song that has become an anthem for the city for which it was named. It is now legendary.

What you probably didn’t know was that this song wasn’t penned by or for Old Blue Eyes, by any stretch of the imagination. It was written by the world-famous songwriting team for Martin Scorsese’s 1977 extravaganza New York, New York -- a throwback/homage to the big studio confections of the '40s and '50s, many of which were directed by star Liza Minnelli’s father Vincente, and starring her mother Judy Garland.

So it makes perfect sense that the song was commissioned by a director and star (Robert De Niro) who has so closely been associated with the Big Apple, and an actress whose very genes were permeated by the genre, and who would also become known most for her Oscar-winning, tune-belting role as Sally Bowles in Cabaret.

In retrospect, and on paper, these pedigrees seem to be a match made in heaven. The finished product, though, is a little bit messy, a little too glossy, and a lot too long (almost three hours!). Candy-coated, and unnaturally colorful, the film opens on VJ Day, 1943, on the streets of New York City. Minnelli’s Francine Evans and De Niro’s Jimmy Doyle meet cute in a USO hall and from there, what passes for a plot unfolds as the firecracker romance between the two becomes the catalyst for the lumbering story.

New York, New York, under a haze of manic glitziness, is ultimately a story about two creative people, on their way to fame, who find it impossible to coexist with or without each other. It is an old-school premise that the director lifts directly from the films he watched as a boy. There’s even an extended scene (which the director says on the extras disc was intentional) that mimics Garland’s “Born in a Trunk” number from A Star is Born (to which Scorsese’s film basically owes everything) but flops.

What Scorsese tries to do, in an era where the musical was mainly dead, is reinvent the genre by mixing the gritty realism of the lives of musical performers on the road, trying to survive in post-World War II New York City with the Busby Berkley-esque flights of fantasy clumsily interspersed with hearty doses of tough Scorsese reality. He celebrates the artifice of the form with obviously painted sets, sparkly costumes, and other whimsical touches throughout.

It’s virtuosic, and ambitious, but feels hollow and ill-conceived, relying too much on improvisation between the actors – De Niro and Minnelli are a downright bizarre match. Sometimes they have chemistry, other times, they’re flatter than pancakes. Minnelli looks blatantly uncomfortable improvising opposite consummate Method man De Niro, though in her interview on the extras disc, she recalls the making of the film with clear affection.

The director’s eye for casting, however, is impeccable. This is a man who has led Don Rickles and Jerry Lewis to their career-best performances. Casting Minnelli was maybe the smartest move on Scorsese’s part. No director (other than Cabaret’s Bob Fosse) has ever elicited such a humane performance from the hard-to-cast Liza.

Scorsese films her like a '40s musical screen goddess, and she repays him with one of her most relaxed, assured acting performances. Scorsese if often accused of being a macho director of men, but it should be pointed out that he has guided 13 women to Oscar nominations. Even though Minnelli was not among the nominated women, it is clear that she took the opportunity and ran with it.

Curiously, the hyphenate’s dramatic scenes are the ones to watch – her attempts at establishing and nurturing her character are valiant and more interesting than her by-the-numbers musical sequences. In fact, in the scenes that should have been a lot more bombastic, the main thing you notice is how awful Minnelli’s lip-synching is.

De Niro, after Taxi Driver, should be commended for stepping as far away from Travis Bickle as he possibly could. The actor is very much outside of his comfort zone as Jimmy, but the stiffness sometimes shows through.

If this film feels dated, that’s on purpose, according to the director. The real mystery, though, is how does this fit overall into the director’s oeuvre? It functions as another New York story, which the director has become synonymous with, it is another “Marty/Bobby” collaboration (their third out of many), and it is another film that romanticizes the director’s adoration for the medium and the moving images that shaped him as a child – likely the most prevalent theme in all of his work.

Scorsese’s insistence on old-school craftsmanship, his slavish devotion to the classic forms of the musical, make the film’s flop even more devastating. It is clear he went into this project with high hopes. Even now, there is a sense in watching him talk about the film, that he is still disappointed by the reception.

The seeming innocuousness of New York, New York belies its actual construction. Yes, this is a clear genre picture, but one that was made immediately following the relentless, ground-breaking Taxi Driver -- one can only wonder which film proved more of a challenge for the director to make.

Still, it is hard to really see this as more than an exercise in nostalgia. The director’s customary passion is there, but there is still something that feels uneven. The Scorsese stamp, however, still holds more credibility and style than a dozen Dreamgirls or Hairsprays. But, unfortunately, this is more of a study in cinematic excess and directorial indulgence. New York, New York is a well-intentioned, well-built oddity. It is reminiscent of other big, noble musical failures such as Woody Allen’s wooden Everyone Says I Love You and Robert Altman’s Popeye.

The failure of New York, New York, after the critical success of Taxi Driver (1976), allegedly sent Scorsese into a tailspin of depression and addiction. In the introduction on this special edition, Scorsese reflects on the picture being “unmanageable” and calls the style “un-definable”. His eloquence and willingness to defend what is likely his worst film, combined with a fearless sense of experimentation, should put to rest any doubts that Scorsese isn’t one of the most consistently interesting American filmmakers.

After seeing this, I couldn’t help but wondering what the modern, mythic filmmaker Scorsese, who has so lovingly embraced new movie-making technologies and aesthetics would do with a musical today. The results would likely be much more vivid and alive.

5

In the wake of Malcolm Young's passing, Jesse Fink, author of The Youngs: The Brothers Who Built AC/DC, offers up his top 10 AC/DC songs, each seasoned with a dash of backstory.

In the wake of Malcolm Young's passing, Jesse Fink, author of The Youngs: The Brothers Who Built AC/DC, offers up his top 10 AC/DC songs, each seasoned with a dash of backstory.

Keep reading... Show less

Pauline Black may be called the Queen of Ska by some, but she insists she's not the only one, as Two-Tone legends the Selecter celebrate another stellar album in a career full of them.

Being commonly hailed as the "Queen" of a genre of music is no mean feat, but for Pauline Black, singer/songwriter of Two-Tone legends the Selecter and universally recognised "Queen of Ska", it is something she seems to take in her stride. "People can call you whatever they like," she tells PopMatters, "so I suppose it's better that they call you something really good!"

Keep reading... Show less

Morrison's prose is so engaging and welcoming that it's easy to miss the irreconcilable ambiguities that are set forth in her prose as ineluctable convictions.

It's a common enough gambit in science fiction. Humans come across a race of aliens that appear to be entirely alike and yet one group of said aliens subordinates the other, visiting violence upon their persons, denigrating them openly and without social or legal consequence, humiliating them at every turn. The humans inquire why certain of the aliens are subjected to such degradation when there are no discernible differences among the entire race of aliens, at least from the human point of view. The aliens then explain that the subordinated group all share some minor trait (say the left nostril is oh-so-slightly larger than the right while the "superior" group all have slightly enlarged right nostrils)—something thatm from the human vantage pointm is utterly ridiculous. This minor difference not only explains but, for the alien understanding, justifies the inequitable treatment, even the enslavement of the subordinate group. And there you have the quandary of Otherness in a nutshell.

Keep reading... Show less
3

A 1996 classic, Shawn Colvin's album of mature pop is also one of best break-up albums, comparable lyrically and musically to Joni Mitchell's Hejira and Bob Dylan's Blood on the Tracks.

When pop-folksinger Shawn Colvin released A Few Small Repairs in 1996, the music world was ripe for an album of sharp, catchy songs by a female singer-songwriter. Lilith Fair, the tour for women in the music, would gross $16 million in 1997. Colvin would be a main stage artist in all three years of the tour, playing alongside Liz Phair, Suzanne Vega, Sheryl Crow, Sarah McLachlan, Meshell Ndegeocello, Joan Osborne, Lisa Loeb, Erykah Badu, and many others. Strong female artists were not only making great music (when were they not?) but also having bold success. Alanis Morissette's Jagged Little Pill preceded Colvin's fourth recording by just 16 months.

Keep reading... Show less
9

Frank Miller locates our tragedy and warps it into his own brutal beauty.

In terms of continuity, the so-called promotion of this entry as Miller's “third" in the series is deceptively cryptic. Miller's mid-'80s limited series The Dark Knight Returns (or DKR) is a “Top 5 All-Time" graphic novel, if not easily “Top 3". His intertextual and metatextual themes resonated then as they do now, a reason this source material was “go to" for Christopher Nolan when he resurrected the franchise for Warner Bros. in the mid-00s. The sheer iconicity of DKR posits a seminal work in the artist's canon, which shares company with the likes of Sin City, 300, and an influential run on Daredevil, to name a few.

Keep reading... Show less
8
Pop Ten
Mixed Media
PM Picks

© 1999-2017 Popmatters.com. All rights reserved.
Popmatters is wholly independently owned and operated.

rating-image