Music

ONO/Tenaglia - "Walking on Thin Ice (Maestro Version)"

The track is a portrait of a body crumpled and floored, knocked off its feet by the intensity of its longing for someone.

Pryor Stroud: Plaintive yet not despondent or utterly without hope, this orchestral-dirge version of "Walking on Thin Ice" showcases Yoko's cracked-glass vocal performance and conscripts the listener into considering the enormity of loss she's felt over a lifetime. The nearly axiomatic simplicity of the verses -- "Why do we forget what's been said / And play the game of life with our hearts?" -- are supremely affecting, giving material form -- via diverging string section tendrils and skittish piano retreats -- to the soul-plummets endemic to the high-risk, low-reward contemplation of foregone love. In short, the track is a portrait of a body crumpled and floored, knocked off its feet by the intensity of its longing for someone, much like how Lennon's body was crumpled around Yoko in the now-famous Annie Leibovitz Rolling Stone cover photograph, except here the body has no one to cling onto; it gropes for flesh that isn't there. [9/10]

Emmanuel Elone: Like almost all Yoko Ono songs, "Walking on Thin Ice" suffers from Ono's childish, comical vocals. However, that's the only thing wrong with this song. A beautiful string section and piano accompany her, and her lyrics are poetic and tasteful. If only someone else was singing them, it would be a neat, lovely tune. [5/10]

Chris Ingalls: Yoko Ono has been getting a bad rap for decades. I'll admit that a lot of her stuff is hard to digest, but she rarely gets credit for her influence on the avant-garde. While I don't feel that her music needs to be "prettied up" for mass consumption, this is quite lovely. Danny Tenaglia's mix puts this classic Ono composition in a new light, pairing up Ono's halting vocals with gorgeous strings and piano. A beautiful re-imagining of an often-ignored classic. [7/10]

Chad MIller: A beautiful orchestral arrangement do this songs wonders. Ono gives a really interesting vocal performance. It adds a touch of cold to the warm strings, and it's really effective. [7/10]

Jasper Bruce: I've never seen anything that validates The Simpsons' parody of Yoko Ono quite so effectively. The video clip is nice, at least. [4/10]

Steve Horowitz: This version of the song is lovely and formal and elegiac all at the same time. Like the smell of flowers in a funeral arrangement, the video adds an element of unexpected charm and a touch of nostalgia to the situation. Oh Yoko… oh my… the ice beneath our feet will inevitably break, but there are mermaids signing in the deep. [8/10]

SCORE: 6.66

The First Record: Aretha's Gold

The concept album that is Aretha's Gold follows the chronology of Aretha Franklin's hits, all released in 1967 and 1968, apex years of the decade not just in terms of numbers but also as an apogee of its cultural and political zeitgeist.

Music
Pop Ten
Mixed Media
PM Picks

© 1999-2018 Popmatters.com. All rights reserved.
Popmatters is wholly independently owned and operated.