PopMatters Picks: The Best TV, Film, and DVDs of 2006
What's more important when making up a year end list -- artistic merit or entertainment value? Are the two mutually exclusive, or are there instances where pure pop value equals cinematic craft? Should one vote with the heart or with the head, does how much you laugh matter less than how hard you cried... or raged... or thought? These are the factors that fluster even the most seasoned cinephile and taunt the television fan. Throughout the course of any particular timeframe, a reviewer is bombarded with a smorgasbord of sound and vision -- movies about hope and heroism, TV shows trading on both humor and heartache. It's a sometimes pleasant, sometimes profound assault on the senses, but remains an attack nonetheless. To ask said victim to turn around and rate their assailants from one to ten is paramount to impossible. Somewhere along the line, omissions will be made and gut reactions will overwhelm intelligence and logic.
So perhaps its best to consider this collection of PopMatters 2006 Picks for the year's outstanding film, DVD, and television fare as less of a legitimate grading of media, and more like a gathering of memories. Or, even better, a recognition of reactions, for in the end, that's what any ranked list really is. You look over the 12 months that have passed, you put on your thinking cap, and try to recall the 10 or 20 titles that made the biggest impact on you. Sure, some outside aesthetics are applied, but in the end, what you're really doing is scoring how significant each experience was. And since it will be filtered through your own sensibility first, and a more generalized awareness second, the result is much more recollected than ranked. As a matter of fact, this should be your approach when reading these pieces.
Instead of wondering why a certain series was overlooked, or how anyone could champion such a crappy motion picture, use these lists as a starting point for your own reminiscences. If we don’t agree, so what? That's the beauty -- and purpose -- of such endeavors.
-- Bill Gibron