PopMatters is moving to WordPress. We will publish a few essays daily while we develop the new site. We hope the beta will be up sometime late next week.

Private (2004)

This film, at its heart, asks the question of how a fundamentally intolerable situation is to be tolerated.


Director: Saverio Costanzo
Cast: Mohammad Bakri, Areen Omari, Hend Ayoub, Lior Miller
Distributor: Typecast Films
MPAA rating: Unrated
Studio: OffSide, Istituto Luce, and Cydonia
First date: 2004
US DVD Release Date: 2006-11-13

Freedom. Democracy. God. Discourse concerning the conflict in the Middle East is often saddled with vague terms and huge ideas, and often at the expense of a genuine understanding of what's at stake for the people who actually live in the region. The Palestinian conflict, for example, is seen (depending on which writers you read or, better yet, which cable news outlet you turn on) as a clash of religions (Islam vs. Judaism) or, even bigger, a clash of civilizations (the East vs. the West). But more often than not, such broad prognostications on both sides of the spectrum are the result of ideology running rampant and spun by demagogues who earn their living and advance their careers by inflating the matter to epic proportions.

But what does the situation look like for those who must earn their living amidst the titanic cataclysm of their environs? Saverio Costanzo's Private offers a revealing portrayal of the conflict as it affects individual lives both in Israel and occupied Palestine. For the characters of the film, abstracts like freedom and religion take a backseat to far more pressing issues such as education, jobs, family, and home. The last of these, in particular, serves as the inspiration for Costanzo's largely allegorical rendering, shot with a handheld camera and presented in long scenes in order to instill a sense of the reality of life for one Palestinian family forced to confront the violence of Israeli occupation.

The film centers on Mohammad, a literature teacher, and Samia, his wife. The couple lives with their five children in a modest, two-story home in the Palestinian countryside -- a dwelling that just happens to be of strategic value to the Israeli army. Consequently, in the dead of one particular night, faces blackened with greasepaint, soldiers kick in the door, brandishing fully automatic weapons and herding the family into their living room. After the yelling and screaming subside, the head soldier invites Mohammad to leave his house. Upon Mohammad's refusal, the soldier informs him that the house now belongs to the Israeli army, and will be comprised of three areas: Area "A" is the living room, to which the family has full access; Area "B" is the kitchen and dining rooms, which the family can visit during certain hours; and Area "C" is the second story bedrooms, which are now off-limits to any family member.

The situation, of course, advances a strong parallel to the conditions in modern Palestine, which is administered entirely by a system of Israeli checkpoints. Palestinians must carry proper identification and credentials to travel between areas, and even then are allowed to pass only at the pleasure of Israeli soldiers who man (and frequently close) the checkpoints themselves. As such, when Mohammad asks to retrieve clothes for his family from the now-restricted area, the Israeli soldier's reply of "Be my guest" takes on a perverse undertone. Mohammad and his family are now guests in their own home, just as Palestinians have been converted into guests in their own land by the Israeli military.

The majority of the film, though, centers on the way in which Mohammad and his family deal with their occupation. At its heart is the question of just how such an intolerable situation is to be tolerated. Mohammad, for his part, refuses to leave, rejecting the prospect of becoming a refugee and instead suggesting that the best way to resist occupation is to strengthen one's ties to land and home. His wife and children, however, disagree. Samia, cut off from her community and forced to spend all day with armed, foreign soldiers stomping around above her, suffers terribly. The eldest son, Yousef, begs to be allowed to stay at a friend's (unoccupied) house, while the eldest daughter Mariam decries the injustice of their situation and argues that fighting and dying as resistors would be preferable to putting up with occupation. Jamal, the middle son, dreams of becoming a martyr and wreaking revenge for the humiliation he and his family are forced to suffer -- a poignant and arrestingly lucid explanation of how "terrorists" are born. Rather than hatred of freedom, or (more ludicrous yet) jealousy of Western privilege, it's all too clear to see that fantasies like Jamal's are created by oppression, violence, and hopelessness. To strike back becomes, for many, the only way one can restore the dignity stripped by the violence of the occupiers.

Such conclusions, however, are not made explicit by the film and, for this, Private is all the more successful. Rather than present a diatribe of ideology or an exploitative melodrama, the film instead traffics in subtleties. The occupation is not shown simply in terms of suicide bombs and F-16s. Instead, it's more artfully rendered, like in a scene where Yousef is forced to concentrate on his homework above the roar of a fighter jet circling above. Later, the occupying soldiers fire their weapons from the family's balcony in the middle of the night. Unable to get back to the family's locked living room (their "prison" room, as it comes to be called), the youngest daughter, Nada, can only take comfort from the glow of her father's lighter, shining softly through the keyhole amid the terrifying din of machine gun fire.

The soldiers, too, are shown as more than merely violent thugs. Watched secretly by Mariam as she hides in an upstairs closet, these occupiers are in fact so many young men, barely into their adulthood and at times bewildered by the position they are forced to take. Most of them would rather watch soccer on TV (one even prefers to play the flute) than make prisoners of a family of strangers. This portrayal, though, just underscores the double tragedy of Israeli occupation. Forced into mandatory service, Israeli soldiers are often as reluctant to participate in occupation as the Palestinians are to suffer its indignities.

The film, then, documents the individual cost of a conflict that is propagated from without. The United States, for example, bears a large portion of the guilt for the kind of heartrending scenes that populate the film by funneling billions in military and economic support to Israel without holding it accountable (like virtually every other country on the planet) for the resulting violence that such support makes possible. In fact, Private is essentially an Italian project, shot in Italy by an Italian director and crew, which speaks to the way in which the rest of the world sees this problem and the way that America does not. Sadly, allegations of anti-Semitism are quick to be hurled by supporters of Israeli occupation, effectively shutting down any substantive discussion of the crisis and allowing the cycle of oppression and revenge to continue unabated.

And it's this concept of a cycle that Private most strikingly underscores for its viewers. The soldiers eventually do leave the house, called away to another mission, but are replaced later that same day by a fresh set of occupiers. As a group, the new soldiers move toward a booby trap set by Jamal, Pink Floyd's Roger Waters can be heard singing "And the Germans kill the Jews, and the Jews kill the Arabs, and the Arabs kill the hostages", pointing to the endless repetition of violence that plagues the film's characters. Finally, it's to the enduring credit of Private and films like it that they are able to distill ideology and flag waving to the individual struggle for dignity and hope in the face of cyclical oppression and revenge.


Please Donate to Help Save PopMatters

PopMatters have been informed by our current technology and hosting provider that we have less than a month, until November 6, to move PopMatters off their service or we will be shut down. We are moving to WordPress and a new host, but we really need your help to save the site.





The 10 Best Horror Movie Remakes

The horror genre has produced some remake junk. In the case of these ten treats, the update delivers something definitive.


Flirting with Demons at Home, or, When TV Movies Were Evil

Just in time for Halloween, a new Blu-ray from Kino Lorber presents sparkling 2K digital restorations of TV movies that have been missing for decades: Fear No Evil (1969) and its sequel, Ritual of Evil (1970).


Magick Mountain Are Having a Party But Is the Audience Invited?

Garage rockers Magick Mountain debut with Weird Feelings, an album big on fuzz but light on hooks.


Aalok Bala Revels in Nature and Contradiction on EP 'Sacred Mirror'

Electronic musician Aalok Bala knows the night is not a simple mirror, "silver and exact"; it phases and echoes back, alive, sacred.


Clipping Take a Stab at Horrorcore with the Fiery 'Visions of Bodies Being Burned'

Clipping's latest album, Visions of Bodies Being Burned, is a terrifying, razor-sharp sequel to their previous ode to the horror film genre.


Call Super's New LP Is a Digital Biosphere of Insectoid and Otherworldly Sounds

Call Super's Every Mouth Teeth Missing is like its own digital biosphere, rife with the sounds of the forest and the sounds of the studio alike.


Laura Veirs Talks to Herself on 'My Echo'

The thematic connections between these 10 Laura Veirs songs and our current situation are somewhat coincidental, or maybe just the result of kismet or karmic or something in the zeitgeist.


15 Classic Horror Films That Just Won't Die

Those lucky enough to be warped by these 15 classic horror films, now available on Blu-ray from The Criterion Collection and Kino Lorber, never got over them.


Sixteen Years Later Wayne Payne Follows Up His Debut

Waylon Payne details a journey from addiction to redemption on Blue Eyes, The Harlot, The Queer, The Pusher & Me, his first album since his 2004 debut.


Every Song on the Phoenix Foundation's 'Friend Ship' Is a Stand-Out

Friend Ship is the Phoenix Foundation's most personal work and also their most engaging since their 2010 classic, Buffalo.


Kevin Morby Gets Back to Basics on 'Sundowner'

On Sundowner, Kevin Morby sings of valleys, broken stars, pale nights, and the midwestern American sun. Most of the time, he's alone with his guitar and a haunting mellotron.


Lydia Loveless Creates Her Most Personal Album with 'Daughter'

Given the turmoil of the era, you might expect Lydia Loveless to lean into the anger, amplifying the electric guitar side of her cowpunk. Instead, she created a personal record with a full range of moods, still full of her typical wit.


Flowers for Hermes: An Interview with Performing Activist André De Shields

From creating the title role in The Wiz to winning an Emmy for Ain't Misbehavin', André De Shields reflects on his roles in more than four decades of iconic musicals, including the GRAMMY and Tony Award-winning Hadestown.


The 13 Greatest Horror Directors of All Time

In honor of Halloween, here are 13 fascinating fright mavens who've made scary movies that much more meaningful.


British Jazz and Soul Artists Interpret the Classics on '​Blue Note Re:imagined'

Blue Note Re:imagined provides an entrance for new audiences to hear what's going on in British jazz today as well as to go back to the past and enjoy old glories.


Bill Murray and Rashida Jones Add Another Shot to 'On the Rocks'

Sofia Coppola's domestic malaise comedy On the Rocks doesn't drown in its sorrows -- it simply pours another round, to which we raise our glass.


​Patrick Cowley Remade Funk and Disco on 'Some Funkettes'

Patrick Cowley's Some Funkettes sports instrumental renditions from between 1975-1977 of songs previously made popular by Donna Summer, Herbie Hancock, the Temptations, and others.


The Top 10 Definitive Breakup Albums

When you feel bombarded with overpriced consumerism disguised as love, here are ten albums that look at love's hangover.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.