Broken Boy Soldiers

Steady, As It Goes: The Raconteurs’ ‘Broken Boy Soldiers’ Turns 15

The Raconteurs’ Broken Boy Soldiers sets itself apart from anything like it, even 15 years later. The band’s debut somehow starts two great stories.

Broken Boy Soldiers
The Raconteurs
Third Man Records
16 May 2006

A “raconteur” is a storyteller.

As storytellers, the Raconteurs literally make a lyric from their biggest song, “Steady, As She Goes”, interesting to read, especially in retrospect: “When you have completed / What you thought you had to do”. There’s a story (or two, really) to be told about this band, and maybe at the end of those stories, we might come to understand better what it is that Brendan Benson, Jack Lawrence, Patrick Keeler, and Jack White thought they had to do.

I was 15 years old and in high school when their debut LP, Broken Boy Soldiers, was released 15 years ago. An unofficial rule of being in high school in the Midwest is that your identity can be based on the sport you play, the extracurricular activities you do, who you date, or what you like. People who remember high school fondly seem to have a healthy balance of these categories; as for me, well, I went all-in on music, and nothing sounded better and more exciting (and more comically subversive) than the White Stripes. In 2006, it was harder for a young music fan to consume information about their favorite artists or find obscure, possibly malicious MP3 files alleging to be demos or bootlegs; in other words, unless you were in the Detroit garage rock scene, the idea that Jack White was anything other than 50% of the White Stripes was not ubiquitous knowledge.

This speaks to the two stories the Raconteurs tell. The first—which we will return to in a moment—is the tale of a fleeting band that came from nowhere, with two absolutely spectacular rock and roll records, and vanished just as quickly. The second is that the Raconteurs appeared like a phoenix risen from the exquisite documentation of Third Man Records’ ongoing series of vault releases. These collections quadrupled the number of live Raconteurs offerings, digging up demos and pressing into vinyl open mic night performances by Jack White and Brendan Benson from the mid-1990s. Ultimately, this led to them unleashing a new third album and subsequent world tour.

In 2006, however, the immense excitement of Broken Boy Soldiers enveloped me as I lay underneath a full-spread poster (torn out from an issue of Entertainment Weekly) that I anxiously taped to my bedroom ceiling. I wondered: Who are these three other dudes? Do I have to hitch my wagon to this new group? What does it mean for Jack White to “leave” the White Stripes? Obviously, side projects were not new in 2006, but this felt like dangerous waters to tread.

It’s hard to remember how the debut sounded back then; yet, it’s quite easy to access how Broken Boy Soldiers sounds today, 15 years after its release, as the story of a band who came to handle their guitar-rocking business over the course of three years, vanish, and then rise from the dead a decade after they disappeared. Most importantly, does it still hold up as a confidently told 34-minute tale spread across ten tracks? Well, sit a spell because it’s a story I love telling! Let’s see if these songs still do everything they thought they needed to.

Steady, As She Goes

What an audacious album opener. You probably heard this song before the record was released (maybe in a Yahoo! Video flash player screening the music video, which featured the gang in go-karts.) Regardless of where you heard it first, you’ve definitely heard it since.


Listening to this album is a long and fruitless hunt for the sickest riff because, as a whole, no single song (other than the obvious) jumps out. That’s bad curb appeal, but once you get into the tracks, you’ll find that “Hands”—among many others—not only encourages both White’s virtuosic guitar playing and his harmonies with Benson. Vocally, this isn’t the closest to Sgt. Pepper these two get, but it’s close.

Broken Boy Solider

This weird third track lets you know that you’re not listening to just another alternative rock album. All respect to The Killer’s Hot Fuss, but that album doesn’t have a bullhorn projecting lyrics, now does it? Honestly, “Broken Boy Soldier” is possibly the greatest thesis statement for White’s claim that they have the “best rhythm section in rock and roll”.

Intimate Secretary

A definitive song for how The Raconteurs really work together, this song truly dumps out the group’s whole bag of tricks: heavy, screamy guitar; brashly affected vocals; Benson’s sunny voice; tender acoustic guitar; Lawrence and Keeler’s supporting vocals; and even a Led Zeppelin homage in the form of a mandolin.


In another universe, this song would’ve been the lead single and done well on every FM alternative rock station (and then, inevitably, these guys still disappear). Buried in the middle of the album, “Together” is an immensely underrated slow jam that, fortunately, both White and The Raconteurs keep in heavy rotation.

Publish with PopMatters

Call for Papers: All Things Reconsidered [MUSIC] May-August 2024

PopMatters Seeks Book Critics and Essayists

Call for Papers: All Things Reconsidered – FILM Winter 2023-24

Submit an Essay, Review, Interview, or List to PopMatters

PopMatters Seeks Music Writers