Secondhand Lions (2003)

Todd R. Ramlow

The phallic imagery of guns as associated with male potency is everywhere in Secondhand Lions.

Secondhand Lions

Director: Tim McCanlies
Cast: Michael Caine, Robert Duvall, Haley Joel Osment, Kyra Sedgwick, Nick Katt, Josh Lucas, Eric Balfour
MPAA rating: PG
Studio: New Line Cinema
First date: 2003
US Release Date: 2003-09-19 (Limited release)

Haley Joel Osment has reached that most dreaded stage in life, adolescence. It's a difficult time for everyone, but perhaps even more so for former child stars, who live their awkwardness in front of the camera and whose success has been predicated on their embodiment of both "innocence" and "precocity." Puberty has undone many a young actor: the E! True Hollywood Story is rife with their spectacular failures. There have been a few who have made it through with their careers intact. Drew Barrymore, Anna Paquin, Leo DiCaprio and even Macaulay Culkin (though we did get to see him self-destruct for years) come to mind.

It doesn't look as if Haley Joel will follow in these latter's footsteps, if Secondhand Lions is any indication. Osment's presence here shows that, unlike the Hollywood casualties alluded to above, his own potential failure won't be because of excessive or self-destructive behavior, but rather because of a steadfast refusal to grow up or mature physically. Throughout, he's obviously uncomfortable in his changing body. He takes mincing steps that are way to small for his now gangly legs, and he always seems to be crouching in on himself. It's a little bit creepy. It's as if he's well aware that his childhood has been his bread and butter, and he's willing his body not to change, so he can remain if not a boy, yet at least not an adult man.

It is a bit jarring then, that Osment's refusal is so clear in Secondhand Lions, in which he plays a young boy very much wanting to grow up, who can't wait to be a "man." The opportunity to begin this rite of passage comes when his mother, Mae (Kyra Sedgwick) drops him off to spend "a few weeks" with his batty old uncles Garth (Michael Caine) and Hub (Robert Duvall).

Curmudgeonly and salty in the extreme, Garth and Hub are initially resentful of Walter's intrusion into their life. In Hub's estimation, he doesn't want "some little sissy boy hanging around all summer." And this attitude is much of the film's problem. Walter's maturation and the lessons he must learn in order to be a "man" directly follow a stereotypical script of heteronormative authority and masculine aggression.

The model of masculinity the uncles offer to Walter is that of the colonial adventurer and oppressor. Set in some unspecified year in the early 1950s, Garth and Hub claim to have spent the last 40 years in Northern Africa. Their indoctrination of Walter involves teaching him "manly" lessons through their "classic" tales of life in the French Foreign Legion and crushing "native" uprisings. Along the way, we are treated to any number of racist caricatures -- turbaned, greedy sheiks, harems, and evil Arab henchmen who pick their teeth with knives.

Obviously, it's not the most progressive of representations, though Garth and Hub's perspective may be close to the truth of colonialist exploitation. But it's a troubling message in a "family film," especially considering the current state of Arab American relations, and the experiences of Arab Americans within the States. Then again, it's precisely this neocolonial cowboy image that Dubya has been promoting in his version of America's role in world affairs and the "war on terrorism."

The model of manhood offered by the uncles, then, is based in an "independence" asserted through the oppression of foreign cultures, and is subtended by the propensity for casual violence, and the rejection of all things feminine.

In their dotage, both Garth and Hub cling to violence as emblem of their manliness. Garth is clearly scared of getting older and losing the physical strength and prowess by which he measured his worth, and so is always itching for or picking a fight. Both men are never far from their guns, using them to "fish" in the pond out back and to scare away traveling salesmen with potshots from the front porch. The phallic imagery of guns as associated with male potency is everywhere in Secondhand Lions.

All this aggression is to help "cure" Walter of his "sissy," "weenie" ways, which are, of course, aligned with femininity. It's hardly surprising that in this homosocial environment women are either "evil," like Mae, who lies incessantly and is, in the uncles' parlance, "loose" or they are, like Garth's one true love Jasmine (Emmanuelle Vaugier), exotic, absolutely perfect, and silent -- not to mention dead.

Suffice it to say, Secondhand Lions takes these lessons in imperial and violent masculinity at face value and by the end little Walter has dutiful learned the trajectory he must follow to become a man. The lack of self-awareness of the film in these regards is rather irresponsible, and a bit surprising, considering that director and writer Tim McCanlies also penned The Iron Giant, a deft critique of intolerance and bigotry.

The only potential saving grace of the film is that just as he learns from his uncles, Walter also teaches them a thing or two about how to survive in a post-colonial, and post-WWII America. The secondary plot of the film concerns the fortune Garth and Hub have amassed during their many travels. Of course everyone wants to know if rumors of the money are true, where/how the men got it, where it's hidden and how they can get their hands on it.

The real scandal of all their money, though, is that Garth and Hub don't know what to do with it. As Walter asks them, "What's the use of having all that money if you don't spend it?" Consumerism and the valorization of the self through material goods are the lessons in post-War masculinity that Walter teaches his uncles. Before Walter shows them how to find their self-worth in their wealth, the men are doomed to live in the past. Once they start spending, their life takes on new richness and meaning and they owe it all to Walter's steadfast materialism. Despite all of his sissy and weenie ways then, Walter represents the soft, suburban, commercialized masculinity emerging in 1950s America. In embracing the consumerism on which that new masculinity would be based, Garth and Hub acknowledge that the model that they represent is as tired and worn out as they are.






Memoir 'Rust' Wrestles with the Myth of the American Dream

Eliese Colette Goldbach's memoir, Rust: A Memoir of Steel and Grit, is the story of one descending into the depths of The American Dream and emerging with flecks of graphite dust on her cheeks, a master's degree in her hands, and a few new friends.


'Indian Sun: The Life and Music of Ravi Shankar' (excerpt)

Ravi Shankar was bemused by the Beatles, Rolling Stones, the Yardbirds and other bands using the sitar in rock music. Enjoy this excerpt of Indian Sun, by Oliver Craske (who worked with Shankar on his 1997 autobiography), courtesy of Hachette Books.

Oliver Craske

The Strokes Phone It In (Again) on 'The New Abnormal'

The Strokes' The New Abnormal is an unabashedly uninspired promotional item for their upcoming world tour.


"I'm an Audience Member, Playing This Music for Us": An Interview With Keller Williams

Veteran musician Keller Williams discusses his special relationship with the Keels, their third album together, Speed, and what he learned from following the Grateful Dead.


Shintaro Kago's 'Dementia 21' Showcases Surrealist Manga

As much as I admire Shintaro Kago's oddness as a writer, his artistic pen is even sharper (but not without problems) as evident in Dementia 21.


Adrian Younge and Ali Shaheed Muhammad Proclaim 'Jazz Is Dead!' Long Live Jazz!

Adrian Younge and Ali Shaheed Muhammad bring their live collaborative efforts with jazz veterans to recorded life with Jazz Is Dead 001, a taste of more music to come.


"I'll See You Later": Repetition and Time in Almodóvar's 'All About My Mother'

There are mythical moments in Almodóvar's All About My Mother. We are meant to register repetition in the story as something wonderfully strange, a connection across the chasm of impossibility.


Electropop's CMON Feel the Noise on 'Confusing Mix of Nations'

Pop duo CMON mix and match contemporary and retro influences to craft the dark dance-pop on Confusing Mix of Nations.


'Harmony' Is About As Bill Frisell As a Bill Frisell Recording Can Be

Bill Frisell's debut on Blue Note Records is a gentle recording featuring a few oddball gems, particularly when he digs into the standard repertoire with Petra Haden's voice out front.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 4, James Chance to the Pop Group

This week we are celebrating the best post-punk albums of all-time and today we have part four with Talking Heads, the Fall, Devo and more.


Raye Zaragoza's "Fight Like a Girl" Shatters the Idea of What Women Can and Can't Do (premiere)

Singer-songwriter and activist Raye Zaragoza's new single, "Fight Like a Girl", is an empowering anthem for intersectional feminism, encouraging resilience amongst all women.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.