Seduced by Madness: The True Story of the Susan Polk Murder Case by Carol Pogash

Bruce Gerstman
Contra Costa Times (MCT)

What makes Pogash's book so powerful is that it evokes the universal bafflement we feel over the tortured relationships some other people endure.

Seduced by Madness: The True Story of the Susan Polk Murder Case

Publisher: William Morrow
ISBN: 0061147702
Author: Carol Pogash
Price: $24.95
Length: 384
Formats: Hardcover
US publication date: 2007-05

Berkeley psychologist Felix Polk knew his sons' piano teacher really well. Same with the baby sitter and many of his friends who came to dinner at his home on a regular basis. They were all his patients. It's not surprising that at some point in his career, he met a patient whom he decided to marry, Susan Bolling.

It is this image of an untraditional therapist who lacked boundaries and developed personal relationships with his patients that Carol Pogash depicts in Seduced by Madness, her new book that covers the Susan Polk murder case: "Felix didn't think that he should be a transparent sounding board on whom the patient could project qualities that could help him. Rather, he saw himself as a friend who talked about himself and involved many of his patients in his life."

At age 44, 20 years into their marriage, Susan Polk stabbed 70-year-old Felix Polk to death in the backyard cottage of their estate in Orinda, Calif. The topic prepares readers for a true crime saga in one of the wealthiest towns in Contra Costa County. However, Pogash did not need to focus on cliff-hanging suspense. She crafted an exceptional piece of literary journalism using interviews with the Polks' family and friends, as well as Felix Polk's former patients and colleagues.

Pogash first tells the story of a man 25 years older than his wife, who loved her so much that despite knowing the dangers she posed, he could not stay away from her. She follows it with the tale of a woman who engineered one of the strangest trials ever in court -- committing antics such as telling the judge that the prosecutor needed a spanking and eliciting testimony from her son on the witness stand that she was being absurd in representing herself.

As depicted in Pogash's book, Susan Polk was a shy teenager with few friends when she met her future husband. They married, and she became the gracious hostess at her husband's parties.

The Orinda housewife appears, early in her marriage, to be a fantasy: an attractive, somewhat naive, but highly intelligent woman who wants one man whom she idolizes and worships. Felix Polk appears to be the ultimate controller, but not in a sinister way. He has control over Susan Polk because she admires and emotionally depends on him as her wise therapist.

People in their circles saw Felix as warm and Susan, cordial. She focused her entire life on raising her three children.

She first became paranoid in the early 1980s, when she formed an organization to stop what she believed to be satanic cults running preschools. Over the next 10 years, her delusions extended to a conviction that Felix Polk was turning judges and law enforcement against the family.

Pogash's qualifications to tell the Polk story go beyond her being a veteran journalist for the San Francisco Examiner. She has the street cred of being a longtime Orinda resident. Having covered this case for the Times, I also grew intimate with the facts and characters.

Pogash got them right, pulled them together and wove a narrative that brings you into the scenes. Her descriptions of towns, people and even rooms are vivid; from Polk's middle son, who "looked as though he had spent the day crying," to her depiction of Polk's former attorney Daniel Horowitz as a media spin doctor who "checked TV's online overnight ratings the way some folks do the temperature."

I never saw Pogash miss a day of court. She dedicates about 40 percent of Seduced to the trial, offering a glimpse into the craziness Susan Polk caused as she acted as her own attorney and fought with the judge, the prosecutor and many witnesses.

The single element of Pogash's story I had a difficult time believing was the depth of love that Felix Polk had for his wife. Susan Polk conveys charm. She can, at times, seem so down-to-earth. But I spent months in court watching her spew insults with such frequency that she appeared to be brimming with hate. It's hard to imagine anyone feeling so dedicated to her.

But perhaps that is exactly what makes Pogash's book so powerful, as it evokes in us that universal bafflement we feel over the tortured relationships some other people endure.





Nazis, Nostalgia, and Critique in Taika Waititi's 'Jojo Rabbit'

Arriving amidst the exhaustion of the past (21st century cultural stagnation), Waititi locates a new potential object for the nostalgic gaze with Jojo Rabbit: unpleasant and traumatic events themselves.


Why I Did Not Watch 'Hamilton' on Disney+

Just as Disney's Frozen appeared to deliver a message of 21st century girl power, Hamilton hypnotizes audiences with its rhyming hymn to American exceptionalism.


LA Popsters Paper Jackets Deliver a Message We Should Embrace (premiere + interview)

Two days before releasing their second album, LA-based pop-rock sextet Paper Jackets present a seemingly prescient music video that finds a way to ease your pain during these hard times.


'Dancing After TEN' Graphic Memoir Will Move You

Art dances with loss in the moving double-memoir by comics artists Vivian Chong and Georgia Webber, Dancing After TEN.


Punk Rock's WiiRMZ Rage at the Dying of the Light on 'Faster Cheaper'

The eight songs on WiiRMZ's Faster Cheaper are like a good sock to the jaw, bone-rattling, and disorienting in their potency.


Chris Stamey Paints in "A Brand-New Shade of Blue" (premiere + interview)

Chris Stamey adds more new songs for the 20th century with his latest album, finished while he was in quarantine. The material comes from an especially prolific 2019. "It's like flying a kite and also being the kite. It's a euphoric time," he says.


Willie Nelson Surveys His World on 'First Rose of Spring'

Country legend Willie Nelson employs his experience on a strong set of songs to take a wide look around him.


Gábor Lázár Is in Something of a Holding Pattern on 'Source'

Experimental electronic artist Gábor Lázár spins his wheels with a new album that's intermittently exciting but often lacking in variety.


Margo Price Is Rumored to Be the New Stevie Nicks

Margo Price was marketed as country rock because of her rural roots. But she was always more rock than country, as one can hear on That's How Rumors Get Started.


DMA'S Discuss Their Dancier New Album 'The Glow'

DMA'S lead-singer, Tommy O'Dell, discusses the band's new album The Glow, and talks about the dancier direction in their latest music.


The Bacon Brothers Deliver Solemn Statement With "Corona Tune" (premiere + interview)

Written and recorded during the 2020 quarantine, "Corona Tune" exemplifies the Bacon Brothers' ability to speak to the gravity of the present moment.


Garage Rockers the Bobby Lees Pay Tribute to "Wendy" (premiere)

The Bobby Lees' "Wendy" is a simmering slice of riot 'n' roll that could have come from the garage or the gutter but brims with punk attitude.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.