Taylor Swift 2026
Photo: TAS Rights Management

Taylor Swift Reprises Schmaltz on ‘The Encore’

On The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore, Taylor Swift does little to change the original album’s reception, but offers harmless fun nonetheless.

The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore
Taylor Swift
Republic
25 September 2026

As a music writer, I may be biased in making the following assumption, but plenty of evidence supports it: Taylor Swift reads criticism of her own work. When asked about this matter in a 2014 interview with Jimmy Kimmel, the singer-songwriter replied, “People who say they don’t care [about reviews] are lying. Everyone cares what the New York Times and Rolling Stone say.”

As pop stars go, Swift has a reputation for studiousness. In a 2015 interview with the Recording Academy, she echoed a common criticism of her album Red, saying it was not “sonically cohesive.” (Ironically, in hindsight, Red’s unabashed sampling of different styles has made it one of Swift’s most beloved works.)

Given the singer’s willingness to acknowledge critical input, the deluxe edition of 2025’s The Life of a Showgirl is a bit confusing. Released nearly a year after the original album, these four bonus tracks, collectively titled The Encore, provided Swift a chance to revise the initial appraisal of Showgirl: that it was trite and derivative of her early work. Coming from an artist known for pivoting to a new sound on each record, Showgirl espoused familiar tropes.

Taylor Swift – Patient Zero

Whether or not this repetitiveness is intentional, Swift doubles down on the schmaltz on The Encore. Like “Wi$h Li$t” and “CANCELLED!” before it, “Cleveland!” suffers from a case of excessive punctuation. An ode to the hometown of Swift’s husband, NFL star Travis Kelce, “Cleveland!” features a spoken-word interlude where the lovestruck pop star proclaims, “You only need to find one person in this world who doesn’t find you completely insufferable / And I have an important announcement to make / I found mine.”

This declaration calls to mind another spoken-word interlude in Taylor Swift’s discography. In 2019’s “ME!”, she said, “Hey, kids! Spelling is fun!”, an attempt at levity that came across as juvenile. Soon after the song’s release, Swift removed this line from further distributions of “ME!”, but its counterpart in “Cleveland!” is likely here to stay. Despite its lack of savviness, the theatricality of Swift’s hymn to the Buckeye state reaches a fever pitch that would be impossible to sustain without some self-awareness. One thing is for certain: Swift will commit to a bit. 

Even when the singer’s perception of the zeitgeist is just off the mark, the tenets of her songwriting still hold up. On The Encore, “Babylon” is a touching reflection on growing up and leaving home; “Pink Clouding” is a belated apology with an irresistible hook; and, via music video, “Patient Zero” is a cinematic feat of true crime. 

In a review of The Encore for Pitchfork, Shaad D’Souza wrote, “Taylor Swift will always have one of the greatest songwriting catalogs of all time. Not even Taylor Swift could take that away from her, but she sure is trying.” Perhaps several consecutive successes distorted Swift’s quality-control parameters: in 2024, the Eras Tour became the highest-grossing concert tour of all time, and in 2025, Swift purchased her master recordings outright after a years-long dispute. 

Taylor Swift – Cleveland!

Early in her career, criticism fueled Swift’s creative innovation. In the aforementioned interview with the Recording Academy, she attributed the inspiration for the blockbuster 1989 to the backlash its predecessor, Red, received. Pop music itself has an interesting relationship to criticism; because of the genre’s reliance on commercialism, even its most conscientious creators can mistakenly ignore helpful guardrails when the public enables them to do so.

Although The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore has yielded some memorable tracks, as a critic, I have to die on the hill that a new idea for its own sake is the true measure of quality. Having undergone several artistic reinventions herself, Swift, I assume, would agree with this notion on principle. Hopefully, she puts it back into practice soon. In the meantime, if inspiration strikes in Cleveland, who would I be to judge? 

RATING 7 / 10
FROM THE POPMATTERS ARCHIVES