PopMatters is moving to WordPress in December. We will continue to publish on this site as we work on the move. We aim to make it a seamless experience for readers.


The Barkley Marathon and Incomprehensible Game Design

Firewatch (Campo Santo, 2016)

The challenge of understanding something enough to beat it is part of the joy of unraveling incomprehensible game design.

Sometime later this month or early next month, thirty-five masochists will meet up in Frozen Head State Park outside Wartburg, Tennessee to run what is widely accepted as the most difficult marathon in the world. The Barkley Marathon, held annually since its inception in 1986, has been finished only sixteen times. It’s a brutal, multiloop, hellscape of a race. It’s also an inspiring example of design.

When we criticize game design, we often bring up the concept of clarity in a variety of forms. How clear is the interface? How clearly does the game communicate its goals? Is progression clear? Does it tell the player where to go next? Or what things that the player is doing wrong? Clarity is an excellent game design goal. Except for when it isn’t.

There is an intentional incomprehensibility to the Barkley Marathon that in many ways is a core to its fascination-inducing success. Take the simple fact that while the race is held in the same general area every year, each marathon’s specific path is changed each time that the race is held. Similarly, while the course is described on a single map, each runner must decipher the map and copy it onto their own documents to the best of their ability. They can carry with them no GPS, no altimeter, and certainly no cell phone. They map their journey by getting their bearing on the first loop, then remembering their surroundings on the second, that is, if they make it that far.

Reaching one's limit in the Barkley Marathon

In no small way, these runners experience the course in the truest sense. By the time that the woods have chewed them up and spit them up, those mountains up ahead become their own challenge. Each brutal climb and bramble-filled tract of land is etched on the runners' memories as well as on their skin. This personalization of the incomprehensible is admirable. The inscrutable is made clear, not through design, but through perseverance, and recognizing what needs to be accomplished next brings with it its own sense of reward. This is why, time and again, when a game has a map feature, hardcore players encourage others not to use it. I turned off the GPS while playing Firewatch recently and can attest to the sense of ownership over the experience that you achieve by getting lost and then in finding your own way.

More than an experiential ownership though, the incomprehensibility of the Barkley Marathon makes you appreciate the land as a local might. The race features no aid stations, just two water drops along the way, and no path is marked. In fact, only about a third of the course is on a trail at all, the rest is through the Appalachian wilderness. Key parts of the course are recognizable, and they’re given nicknames like “Rat Jaw” and “Danger Dave’s Climbing Wall,” things you might hear described around the local watering hole. Like a local, the runners will add their own story to each location.

The way lived locations become myth is mirrored in the way that we talk about certain games. Your failed attempt at beating Battletoads may go down as legend among your group of friends. We can see legends like these in the making today whenever someone creates and then beats their own brutally difficult Super Mario Maker level. The challenge of understanding something enough to beat it is part of the joy of unraveling incomprehensible game design.

Of course, the absurd difficulty of the five-loop, 100+ mile marathon is a huge part of its allure. In the 2015 documentary about the race, the marathon's creator Gary Cantrell describes the value in the confronting the extreme: “If you’re going to face a real challenge, it has to be a real challenge. You can’t accomplish anything without the possibility of failure.”

The brutally difficult Devil Daggers.

This is a realm so rarely approached by games, the painful meld of difficulty and incomprehensibility. Games like Dark Souls, or more recently Devil Daggers, embrace this approach. Two very different games, one an action-RPG, the other a hellish shooter, but both ask a great deal from their players. Importantly, every victory in the game, even if you never finish them or even surpass your own personal best, are rewarding in the pursuit. To some extent competitive games like League of Legends are appealing for the same reason, feeling rewarded simply in the pursuit of nothing but a game well played.

One of the 2012 Barkley Marathon runners had this to say after he gave up after his third loop: “Sometimes when something defeats us we feel a need to go back and prove something, to ourselves I guess. I don’t feel that way about this. It was just, I gave everything I had and it wasn’t enough and I’m okay with that.”

It’s rare to feel ourselves so tested in games, so confronted with the inscrutable and insurmountable, largely because the concept goes against so much of what we think about good game design. When put ourselves in that space though, our experiences can border on the profound. Cantrell’s approach to the Barkley Marathon mirrors this sentiment: “You like to see people have the opportunity to really find out that something about themselves.”

Please Donate to Help Save PopMatters

PopMatters have been informed by our current technology provider that we have until December to move off their service. We are moving to WordPress and a new host, but we really need your help to fund the move and further development.





ABBA's 'Super Trouper' at 40

ABBA's winning – if slightly uneven – seventh album Super Trouper is reissued on 45rpm vinyl for its birthday.


The Mountain Goats Find New Sonic Inspiration on 'Getting Into Knives'

John Darnielle explores new sounds on his 19th studio album as the Mountain Goats—and creates his best record in years with Getting Into Knives.


The 100 Best Albums of the 2000s: 60-41

PopMatters' coverage of the 2000s' best recordings continues with selections spanning Swedish progressive metal to minimalist electrosoul.


Is Carl Neville's 'Eminent Domain' Worth the Effort?

In Carl Neville's latest novel, Eminent Domain, he creates complexities and then shatters them into tiny narrative bits arrayed along a non-linear timeline.


Horrors in the Closet: Horrifying Heteronormative Scapegoating

The artificial connection between homosexuality and communism created the popular myth of evil and undetectable gay subversives living inside 1950s American society. Film both reflected and refracted the homophobia.


Johnny Nash Refused to Remember His Place

Johnny Nash, part rock era crooner, part Motown, and part reggae, was too polite for the more militant wing of the Civil Rights movement, but he also suffered at the hands of a racist music industry that wouldn't market him as a Black heartthrob. Through it all he was himself, as he continuously refused to "remember his place".


John Hollenbeck Completes a Trilogy with 'Songs You Like a Lot'

The third (and final?) collaboration between a brilliant jazz composer/arranger, the Frankfurt Radio Big Band, vocalists Kate McGarry and Theo Bleckman, and the post-1950 American pop song. So great that it shivers with joy.


The Return of the Rentals After Six Years Away

The Rentals release a space-themed album, Q36, with one absolute gem of a song.


Matthew Murphy's Post-Wombats Project Sounds a Lot Like the Wombats (And It's a Good Thing)

While UK anxiety-pop auteurs the Wombats are currently hibernating, frontman Matthew "Murph" Murphy goes it alone with a new band, a mess of deprecating new earworms, and revived energy.


The 100 Best Albums of the 2000s: 80-61

In this next segment of PopMatters' look back on the music of the 2000s, we examine works by British electronic pioneers, Americana legends, and Armenian metal provocateurs.


In the Tempest's Eye: An Interview with Surfer Blood

Surfer Blood's 2010 debut put them on the map, but their critical sizzle soon faded. After a 2017 comeback of sorts, the group's new record finds them expanding their sonic by revisiting their hometown with a surprising degree of reverence.


Artemis Is the Latest Jazz Supergroup

A Blue Note supergroup happens to be made up of women, exclusively. Artemis is an inconsistent outing, but it dazzles just often enough.


Horrors in the Closet: A Closet Full of Monsters

A closet full of monsters is a scary place where "straight people" can safely negotiate and articulate their fascination and/or dread of "difference" in sexuality.


'Wildflowers & All the Rest' Is Tom Petty's Masterpiece

Wildflowers is a masterpiece because Tom Petty was a good enough songwriter by that point to communicate exactly what was on his mind in the most devastating way possible.


Jazz Composer Maria Schneider Takes on the "Data Lords" in Song

Grammy-winning jazz composer Maria Schneider released Data Lords partly as a reaction to her outrage that streaming music services are harvesting the data of listeners even as they pay musicians so little that creativity is at risk. She speaks with us about the project.


The 100 Best Albums of the 2000s: 100-81

PopMatters' best albums of the 2000s begin with a series of records that span epic metal, ornate indie folk, and a terrifying work of electronic music.


The Power of Restraint in Sophie Yanow, Paco Roca, and Elisa Macellari's New Graphic Novels

The magical quality that makes or breaks a graphic novel lies somewhere in that liminal space in which art and literature intersect.


'People of the City' Is an Unrelenting Critique of Colonial Ideology and Praxis

Cyprian Ekwensi's People of the City is a vivid tale of class struggle and identity reclamation in the shadows of colonialism's reign.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.