Games

The Failed Character Arc of Booker DeWitt in 'Bioshock Infinite'

Booker gets the narrative short shrift compared to the city, and as a result, the game’s final moments suffer.

This post contains spoilers for Bioshock Infinite.

Bioshock Infinite is a game about a lot of things: Racism, sexism, nationalism, religion, and how all those things interact and influence each other. But in actuality, all those –isms are just window dressing to help establish the setting. Bioshock Infinite isn’t about Columbia the same way that Bioshock is about Rapture. Infinite is really a character-driven story about Booker Dewitt and Elizabeth. It’s about how guilt and forgiveness can influence our lives and change who we are. Unfortunately, the game spends more time telling the story of Columbia than the story of Booker and Elizabeth, even though the latter is clearly what this game is actually about. The characters, or rather Booker specifically, gets the narrative short shrift compared to the city, and as a result, the game’s final moments suffer.

The final revelation that Booker and Comstock are two branches of the same person, one consumed with guilt and the other consumed with forgiveness, just doesn’t work for me. The game toys with a fascinating theme -- that one can abuse the forgiveness inherent in religion to justify countless atrocities -- and its attempt to make that theme personal by applying it to the player character is ambitious and worthy of praise, but it ultimately doesn’t work because the game doesn’t set up enough parallels between these two characters. I can’t believe they were ever the same person.

The game wants to explore how we construct an identity by showing us the parallel lives of this intrinsically violent man. How does he deal with that violent side of himself and how does that change him? In one life, he regrets that violence and tries to repent, which sadly only leads to more violence. In the other life, he feels forgiven for that violence, which frees him to commit even greater acts of atrocity. This kind of parallel character arc is a wonderful idea, but it never manifests itself in the game proper. Booker is never compared to Comstock or vice versa. In fact, the game does more to compare Comstock with rebel leader Daisy Fitzroy than with Booker, thus undermining its most important character arc.

Instead of creating parallels, the game falls into the trap of defining these two men as archetypes. Comstock is the villain, Booker is the hero, and every time that they speak, they reinforce this distinction between them. That would be fine for any other game, but not in this case. They should be different, but they shouldn’t be that different.

The game needed to make Booker a genuine anti-hero. It needed to hammer home the fact that Booker DeWitt is not a good person. It flirts with this idea, but never delves into it enough to make it a central focus for the character. Making things worse, every time that the game begins to suggest that Booker is a bad guy, it immediately reverses course to make him seem more sympathetic.

There are a few small conversations with Elizabeth where he flat out tells her that he’s not a good person. But actions speak louder than words, and his actions throughout the game prove him to be a good person at heart -- the “roguish type” as Elizabeth puts it. He admits to doing bad things in the past, but his clear regret for his actions makes it easy for us to forgive him and like him. His few acts of intimate, excessive violence are immediately forgiven or forgotten. You can execute Slate, but as soon as you pull the trigger, Elizabeth admits you were being more merciful than cruel. When Booker downs Comstock, Elizabeth is shocked at first but then she quickly gets over it and runs ahead.

One could make an argument that the general act of gameplay is itself an ultra violent act that should make us question the moral grounding of Booker, but as a gamer, I’ve been trained to assume that gameplay and narrative exist as largely separate entities unless specifically stated otherwise. And Bioshock Infinite doesn’t state otherwise. Elizabeth never comments on your violent shootings save for a brief moment in the beginning, but she very quickly comes to accept all the violence Booker causes while admonishing Comstock for the violence he causes.

If the game, through Elizabeth, lets us know that this violence was unusual and horrific and Booker kept at it regardless, the final twist would feel more natural and maybe there wouldn’t be so many articles about how out-of-place the violence feels within the context of the story.

We need Elizabeth to admonish Booker since she’s the moral center of the game and the filter through which we see Booker. Since this is a first-person game, we can’t see how Booker reacts to things. We need Elizabeth to explain him to us. At the Hall of Heroes, she says “I can see what Slate said has upset you,” and through that bit of dialogue, we learn that Slate’s words of praise for the battle at Wounded Knee have hurt Booker on a deep level we simply can’t see. She’s also the only one whose admonishment would carry any emotional weight. Every other character is so flawed in their own right that their admonishment would seem manipulative or self serving. Booker talks crap about himself quite a bit, but every time he does so, it makes him seem remorseful and thus more roguish -- a man who does violence, but doesn’t enjoy violence. Elizabeth is a painfully honest moral center, and she accepts Booker for all that he is and all that he does, so we never once think to see him as a villain or even as much of an anti-hero. He’s always “the roguish type.”

This makes the hero seem more heroic and sets him up in contrast to the villain, not in parallel to him. I know that one of the central thematic points of the game is that they are so different, that Booker was literally born again in the baptismal waters and that faith, forgiveness, and guilt, the things we hold on to and obsess over, can change us into very different people. But “very different” doesn’t mean “total opposite,” and Bioshock Infinite sets up these two men as total opposites.

The emotional impact of the ending is another unfortunate casualty of Booker’s mismanaged character arc. The ending should be an emotional scene, a father sacrificing himself for his daughter -- hell, Bioshock 2 ended the same way and had me in tears -- but in Bioshock Infinite, my mind is too busy trying to reconcile the final twist that I never stop to consider what Booker’s sacrifice means for him and Elizabeth. In short, the ending is so intellectually confusing that it undermines its inherent tragedy. The revelation that you are Comstock feels less like the last missing piece of a narrative puzzle and more like an extra piece that doesn’t neatly fit into the narrative puzzle I’ve been building. I’m too distracted by this new information to care that Booker dies and erases Elizabeth from existence in the process.

The game does an excellent job constructing a city that’s both beautiful and disturbing, as well as a city that’s realistically dealing with the fallout of trans-dimensional travel/spying: from the Magical Melodies ad of “Tomorrow’s Songs, Today” to the Lutece statue in the beginning that keeps changing from Robert to Rosalind as if the world can’t make up its mind since both existed in this universe at the same time. The game is good at making abstract ideas relatable and understandable, but Bioshock Infinite is better at creating a world than it is at creating characters. Booker’s arc revolves around the idea of a violent man sacrificing himself for repentance, but if I don’t buy that he was a violent man, then I can’t buy his repentance, and if I don’t buy his repentance, then I can’t buy his transformation into Comstock, and if I can’t buy his transformation, then I can’t buy his entire character arc.


Music

Books

Film

Recent
Books

'We're Not Here to Entertain' Is Not Here to Break the Cycle of Punk's Failures

Even as it irritates me, Kevin Mattson's We're Not Here to Entertain is worth reading because it has so much direct relevance to American punks operating today.

Film

Uncensored 'Native Son' (1951) Is True to Richard Wright's Work

Compared to the two film versions of Native Son in more recent times, the 1951 version more acutely captures the race-driven existential dread at the heart of Richard Wright's masterwork.

Music

3 Pairs of Boots Celebrate Wandering on "Everywhere I Go" (premiere)

3 Pairs of Boots are releasing Long Rider in January 2021. The record demonstrates the pair's unmistakable chemistry and honing of their Americana-driven sound, as evidenced by the single, "Everywhere I Go".

Books

'World War 3 Illustrated #51: The World We Are Fighting For'

World War 3 Illustrated #51 displays an eclectic range of artists united in their call to save democracy from rising fascism.

Music

Tiphanie Doucet's "You and I" Is an Exercise in Pastoral Poignancy (premiere)

French singer-songwriter Tiphanie Doucet gives a glimpse of her upcoming EP, Painted Blue, via the sublimely sentimental ode, "You and I".

Music

PM Picks Playlist 3: WEIRDO, Psychobuildings, Lili Pistorius

PopMatters Picks Playlist features the electropop of WEIRDO, Brooklyn chillwavers Psychobuildings, the clever alt-pop of Lili Pistorius, visceral post-punk from Sapphire Blues, Team Solo's ska-pop confection, and dubby beats from Ink Project.

By the Book

The Story of Life in 10 1/2 Species (excerpt)

If an alien visitor were to collect ten souvenir life forms to represent life on earth, which would they be? This excerpt of Marianne Taylor's The Story of Life in 10 and a Half Species explores in text and photos the tiny but powerful earthling, the virus.

Marianne Taylor
Film

Exploitation Shenanigans 'Test Tube Babies' and 'Guilty Parents' Contend with the Aftermath

As with so many of these movies about daughters who go astray, Test Tube Babies blames the uptight mothers who never told them about S-E-X. Meanwhile, Guilty Parents exploits poor impulse control and chorus girls showing their underwear.

Music

Deftones Pull a Late-Career Rabbit Out of a Hat with 'Ohms'

Twenty years removed from Deftones' debut album, the iconic alt-metal outfit gel more than ever and discover their poise on Ohms.

Music

Arcade Fire's Will Butler Personalizes History on 'Generations'

Arcade Fire's Will Butler creates bouncy, infectious rhythms and covers them with socially responsible, cerebral lyrics about American life past and present on Generations.

Film

What 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' Gets Right (and Wrong) About America

Telling the tale of the cyclops through the lens of high and low culture, in O'Brother, Where Art Thou? the Coens hammer home a fatalistic criticism about the ways that commerce, violence, and cosmetic Christianity prevail in American society .

Music

Thelonious Monk's Recently Unearthed 'Palo Alto' Is a Stellar Posthumous Live Set

With a backstory as exhilarating as the music itself, a Thelonious Monk concert recorded at a California high school in 1968 is a rare treat for jazz fans.

Music

Jonnine's 'Blue Hills' Is an Intimate Collection of Half-Awake Pop Songs

What sets experimental pop's Jonnine apart on Blue Hills is her attention to detail, her poetic lyricism, and the indelibly personal touch her sound bears.

Music

Renegade Connection's Gary Asquith Indulges in Creative Tension

From Renegade Soundwave to Renegade Connection, electronic legend Gary Asquith talks about how he continues to produce infectiously innovative music.

Music

A Certain Ratio Return with a Message of Hope on 'ACR Loco'

Inspired by 2019's career-spanning box set, legendary Manchester post-punkers A Certain Ratio return with their first new album in 12 years, ACR Loco.

Books

Oscar Hijuelos' 'Mambo Kings Play the Songs of Love' Dances On

Oscar Hijuelos' dizzyingly ambitious foot-tapping family epic, Mambo Kings Play the Songs of Love, opened the door for Latinx writers to tell their stories in all their richness.

Music

PM Picks Playlist 2: Bamboo Smoke, LIA ICES, SOUNDQ

PopMatters Picks Playlist features the electropop of Bamboo Smoke, LIA ICES' stunning dream folk, Polish producer SOUNDQ, the indie pop of Pylon Heights, a timely message from Exit Kid, and Natalie McCool's latest alt-pop banger.

Film

'Lost Girls and Love Hotels' and Finding Comfort in Sadness

William Olsson's Lost Girls and Love Hotels finds optimism in its message that life tears us apart and puts us back together again differently.


Reviews
Collapse Expand Reviews



Features
Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.