PopMatters is moving to WordPress in December. We will continue to publish on this site as we work on the move. We aim to make it a seamless experience for readers.


Critical Watchdog: Handicapping the 2012 "Album of the Year" Lists

In the past few days, Uncut, Mojo, and Paste have released their Album of the Year lists, and AllMusic is dropping theirs throughout the week. Some quick analysis shows that it's pretty obvious what the #1 record of the year is going to be for a lot of publications...

With early returns from Mojo, Uncut, and Paste already pouring in, we're beginning to develop a clear picture of what this year's Album of the Year race is starting to shape up as, and it’s pretty darn interesting.

Presently, with a #2 showing at Mojo, #5 with Uncut, and a penthouse position with Paste (on top of glowing reviews from all across the spectrum), it's safe to say that Frank Ocean's channel ORANGE is 2012's universally accepted favorite. Additionally, there is a good 90% chance it will top Pitchfork's tally, and numerous other publications will have it easily in their Top 10, most likely keeping it in their Top 3. Yet Ocean's victory comes at a price: while channel ORANGE is quite extraordinary and often very gutting, what a lot of critical institutions will "hear" is the backstory, with Ocean's heartfelt admission of his sexuality being accepted in the hip-hop community taking more ink than the music that inspired his revelation, these two events in tandem marking a watershed moment for a notoriously homophobic genre that will be celebrated for years to come. This being said, keep an eye on write-ups that appear about channel ORANGE, and see if the conversation is more about the album itself or what Ocean's closet-destroying moment signifies in a cultural context. Critics very much want to be on the right side of history, but is channel ORANGE an achievement for its bold sexual politics or because it's just a great album?

Let's be honest: channel ORANGE is a very good album, yet not flawless, and assuredly not a breezy listen by any means: thematically, Ocean's characters are damaged, broken, bored, and confused, and his music features none of the trappings of modern commercial radio (save the excellent "Benny & the Jets"-aping "Super Rich Kids [ft. Earl Sweatshirt]", which is a pretty darned flawless pop song). The between-song skits -- tape-recorded conversations about struggling families, one-off song scraps that fade away as soon as they appear -- give the album the illusion of narrative, but these bits of sonic ephemera succeed more in setting the stark, confessional mood Ocean is going for. It's a solid album, an undisputed highlight for 2012, but be mindful of the write-ups you see and how, exactly, they treat Ocean's breakthrough moment both artistically and culturally. The worry is that some publications may "hear" everything but the actual music.

Expect rock publications like Mojo to hail Jack White's first solo venture as one of the best of the year (Uncut has it coming in very close at #3), as it fits perfectly with rock critics' "Jack White is the savior of the six-string" narrative. There are inherent problems with the album (which I detailed in my 6/10 review for PopMatters), but these slights will be overlooked by the ruling class of rock outlets as 2012 was a good but not extraordinary year for rock music, and White is an easy standby for kudos in this regard (some would argue too easy). It’s a fair bet to say Rolling Stone will give it Top Five placement.

Grimes has enough love to pop up in more than a few Top 10s, likely garnering a Top 20 finish in the Village Voice Pazz & Jop rankings come January (and an even more outside chance of a Grammy nomination or two in next week’s announcement), as electro-pop lovers are again looking for a savior, and Grimes was one of the better, more mainstream-leaning examples this year. Expect a lot of publications to let the dream pop of Beach House get a lot of Top 10 features, but despite their "best yet" kudos, very few outlets would actually give this poll-topping placement (it'll get a decent amount of Top Fives but little more), as Beach House won’t do well outside of indie-friendly critical circles.

One of the most fascinating bellwethers of a publication's critical clout in 2012 will be whether or not they include Swans' punishing double-disc set The Seer. Aside from being Gira & Co.'s commercial breakthrough (amazingly, their debut sales week was enough to give the decades-old band their first Billboard chart position ever), the critical accolades have come fast and furious. What's so surprising then? The fact that Paste, Mojo, and Uncut left it out of their rankings. Swans don’t have the same commercial inroads that, say, Neil Young has had with Psychedelic Pill (which you’ll see in a lot of those aforementioned “rock” publications, like Uncut), although a lot of lighter indie publications may stay away given how brutal the record is. It’s been oft-discussed here between the staff at PopMatters, so we’ll see how it shakes out.

Last but not least, Fiona Apple will place solidly, and a late release for Kendrick Lamar could guarantee him some needed kudos. Odd man out? A December release for Big Boi’s new album, which will leave him out of a lot of critical circles but, depending on how it turns out, will get him ranked up with some late-blooming publications, all the way up to Pazz & Jop and back.

So what have we missed dear readers? What records will blow up in the critical countdown, and which ones are the publications going to miss? How will Ocean’s record be judged, and most importantly, will it stand the test of time? Sound off in the comments -- we can’t wait to hear.

Please Donate to Help Save PopMatters

PopMatters have been informed by our current technology provider that we have until December to move off their service. We are moving to WordPress and a new host, but we really need your help to fund the move and further development.





Jefferson Starship Soar Again with 'Mother of the Sun'

Rock goddess Cathy Richardson speaks out about honoring the legacy of Paul Kantner, songwriting with Grace Slick for the Jefferson Starship's new album, and rocking the vote to dump Trump.


Black Diamond Queens: African American Women and Rock and Roll (excerpt)

Ikette Claudia Lennear, rumored to be the inspiration for Mick Jagger's "Brown Sugar", often felt disconnect between her identity as an African American woman and her engagement with rock. Enjoy this excerpt of cultural anthropologist Maureen Mahon's Black Diamond Queens, courtesy of Duke University Press.

Maureen Mahon

Ane Brun's 'After the Great Storm' Features Some of Her Best Songs

The irresolution and unease that pervade Ane Brun's After the Great Storm perfectly mirror the anxiety and social isolation that have engulfed this post-pandemic era.


'Long Hot Summers' Is a Lavish, Long-Overdue Boxed Set from the Style Council

Paul Weller's misunderstood, underappreciated '80s soul-pop outfit the Style Council are the subject of a multi-disc collection that's perfect for the uninitiated and a great nostalgia trip for those who heard it all the first time.


ABBA's 'Super Trouper' at 40

ABBA's winning – if slightly uneven – seventh album Super Trouper is reissued on 45rpm vinyl for its birthday.


The Mountain Goats Find New Sonic Inspiration on 'Getting Into Knives'

John Darnielle explores new sounds on his 19th studio album as the Mountain Goats—and creates his best record in years with Getting Into Knives.


The 100 Best Albums of the 2000s: 60-41

PopMatters' coverage of the 2000s' best recordings continues with selections spanning Swedish progressive metal to minimalist electrosoul.


Is Carl Neville's 'Eminent Domain' Worth the Effort?

In Carl Neville's latest novel, Eminent Domain, he creates complexities and then shatters them into tiny narrative bits arrayed along a non-linear timeline.


Horrors in the Closet: Horrifying Heteronormative Scapegoating

The artificial connection between homosexuality and communism created the popular myth of evil and undetectable gay subversives living inside 1950s American society. Film both reflected and refracted the homophobia.


Johnny Nash Refused to Remember His Place

Johnny Nash, part rock era crooner, part Motown, and part reggae, was too polite for the more militant wing of the Civil Rights movement, but he also suffered at the hands of a racist music industry that wouldn't market him as a Black heartthrob. Through it all he was himself, as he continuously refused to "remember his place".


John Hollenbeck Completes a Trilogy with 'Songs You Like a Lot'

The third (and final?) collaboration between a brilliant jazz composer/arranger, the Frankfurt Radio Big Band, vocalists Kate McGarry and Theo Bleckman, and the post-1950 American pop song. So great that it shivers with joy.


The Return of the Rentals After Six Years Away

The Rentals release a space-themed album, Q36, with one absolute gem of a song.


Matthew Murphy's Post-Wombats Project Sounds a Lot Like the Wombats (And It's a Good Thing)

While UK anxiety-pop auteurs the Wombats are currently hibernating, frontman Matthew "Murph" Murphy goes it alone with a new band, a mess of deprecating new earworms, and revived energy.


The 100 Best Albums of the 2000s: 80-61

In this next segment of PopMatters' look back on the music of the 2000s, we examine works by British electronic pioneers, Americana legends, and Armenian metal provocateurs.


In the Tempest's Eye: An Interview with Surfer Blood

Surfer Blood's 2010 debut put them on the map, but their critical sizzle soon faded. After a 2017 comeback of sorts, the group's new record finds them expanding their sonic by revisiting their hometown with a surprising degree of reverence.


Artemis Is the Latest Jazz Supergroup

A Blue Note supergroup happens to be made up of women, exclusively. Artemis is an inconsistent outing, but it dazzles just often enough.


Horrors in the Closet: A Closet Full of Monsters

A closet full of monsters is a scary place where "straight people" can safely negotiate and articulate their fascination and/or dread of "difference" in sexuality.


'Wildflowers & All the Rest' Is Tom Petty's Masterpiece

Wildflowers is a masterpiece because Tom Petty was a good enough songwriter by that point to communicate exactly what was on his mind in the most devastating way possible.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.