Do We Already Know the Answer to the Question, 'Are Men Animals?'

Matthew Gutmann's Are Men Animals is and interesting but flawed, rushed look at masculinity that suffers from digressions and an unwillingness to be as political as it could have been.

Are Men Animals? How Modern Masculinity Sells Men Short
Matthew Gutmann

Basic Books

November 2019


Matthew Gutmann's Are Men Animals?: How Modern Masculinity Sells Men Short starts promisingly. His premise is simple enough, but in that simplicity there are some major problems. He writes: "I believe that the ways in which people think about men and expect men to behave can be dramatically renegotiated." It's certainly a compelling statement that's hard to deny.

Unfortunately, there isn't much provided in the way of how we can renegotiate these expectations. "Acting as if men can't control themselves is hazardous," he writes. He argues (not a hard position to take) that women are central to the lives of most men, and he looks at the origins of masculinity. There are myths and half-myths. Do men really spend less time in parental activities than women? Are there really no social structures on earth run by women?

Gutmann travels through Mexico and Shanghai to look at cultures of masculinity beyond US borders. He's looking for clues, for counter-histories to write something different. His approach to the subject is effective to a point, but there's no sense (even in these early pages) that the result of his work is unique.

Are men genetically pre-conditioned to commit sexual assault? Is rape and murder pre-destined and eventual because of destiny? Gutmann considers the notion that more such acts would occur if men thought they could get away with it, but this mixture of anthropological and gender studies clashing with a cursory look at the legal system is tough to swallow when it's not done in equal parts. In his opening Chapter "Gender Confusion", Gutman argues that The Human Genome Project of the '90s was "…after eugenics, the second major push of the century for…'hereditarian scientific ideology.' He asserts that the concept of "Gender Confusion" (aligning with traditional male roles of hunter and provider) is historical and cultural.

The problem here is simple. To propose we are "confused" about gender identity and social roles suggests that there is in fact a definite way to see men on their own and as reflected through their relationships with women. Gutmann continues to ask that we renegotiate what it means to be a man, but he leaves the reader at a loss by never proposing what that new masculine identity should be. By opening with a discussion on gender confusion, he implies that trans identity (which is given a very minor consideration in this book) is complicating rather than enhancing a progressive sense of gender fluidity.

Indeed, "The Science of Maleness" chapter has some problematic conclusions. In particular, Gutmann proposes that aggression elevates testosterone secretion, not the other way around. He proposes that murderers are predominantly men ("…about nine men commit murder for every one woman…"), and he indicates that some researchers have simply surrendered to the idea that men are, by and large, destined to murder. It's an interesting notion, but once again he seems to contradict himself by noting "…most men never kill or even commit assault."

The problem here is that Gutmann introduces these ideas but he doesn't fully explore them, as the informed reader would hope to happen. Does he believe men are doomed? Gutmann's argument is strongest when he makes his connections between human and animal males. Are we all that similar? He writes: "The words we use and the meanings behind them influence how we understand human relationships and events."

Later, he makes a strong argument about the way we are as a species and how we can be better: "Humans don't have to act like other animals…To lose sight of human mutability and the range of behavior among humans is to give men a morphological free pass to tyrannize others under the guise of 'acting like a guy.'"

Gutmann carefully brings us through men's libidos and natural aggressions. Why do men make war? He draws connections between the fact that sex workers of The Dominican Republic were used to satiate the sexual compulsion of UN Peacekeeping forces and the inherent male trait for aggression. Is rape really "…rooted in a feature of human nature," as proposed by psychologist Steven Pinker? Gutmann introduces these ideas and then shuts them down: "Men's bodies are biologically no more or less choosy, coy, or capricious than women's."

This is a long chapter that could very well have been expanded to better purposes, especially when he includes Donald Trump (not by name, but we all know the story) in his example of "Bad" violence and "Good" violence. He re-prints the transcript of Trump's famous "Grab 'em by the pussy" interview with Access Hollywood and asserts that the greatest sin here was not that Trump said these words. Instead, there was "…complicity in the acquiescence, and that collusion was rooted in bedrock beliefs about men and women and violence." In other words, the nation got what it wanted when it voted for him, and there is nobody to blame but ourselves for the consequences.

The more interesting and effective chapters are set in Mexico and China. Regarding the latter, "Reverting to Natural Genders in China" looks at Shanghai's Blind Date Corner, where aged parents meet with matchmakers to offer their children as prospective mates. This is a place where "…the intellectual and career accomplishments of daughters are generally included on their flyers, along with their physical attractiveness. Men's flyers list their height, professional trajectory, and whether they can already provide housing…" The argument is that there are three genders in China, and their third gender is women with PhDs. Gutman adds: "It didn't take long before a fourth gender was added: men married to women with PhDs.

"Biology can't be changed, and it won't matter (as Gutmann notes about Mexico) if the transit system offers gender-segregated train cars to eliminate (or cut down on) crimes against women. Gutmann seems to rush through other issues in the later chapters: pronoun choices, Bret Kavanaugh's Supreme Court nomination case, and the all-pervasive truth of "toxic masculinity". It's a whirlwind of issues that Gutmann presents, but the volume of material should not be perceived as a comprehensive answer to whether or not men are animals.

"If we accept that violence is a core feature rather than a flaw of male behavior, and that assault is men's essential nature reasserting itself, we cripple our ability to identify and combat misogyny, gender bias, and discrimination." It's hard to dispute this, but the rushed sense of this book's final third gives the impression that Gutmann preferred to stuff his text with ideas and perspectives that would please all sides. Had he been more brave and emphasized the political consequences of toxic masculinity, this could have been a stronger book, even incendiary, as we all wait a possible second Trump presidency, where the worst aspects of manhood (primitive, predatory, animalistic) are elevated and rewarded.

The ground Gutmann walks throughout these pages is flat and wide, well-worn by those who came before him. He's not forging any new paths here that can't be accessed through deeper texts, different texts. Testosterone: An Unauthorized Biography by Rebecca M. Jordan-Young and Katrina Karkazis, and Stephen Pinker's The Better Angels of our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined that have done a better job looking at the nature of violence and masculinity as expressed by men.

There is sound and solid research to be found about the way men are perceived in Mexico and China, but Gutmann's questions on gender identity are problematic. His presumption that there is a definitive notion of masculinity hurts this book's potential to make a major difference. Most of us can already answer the title's question: Yes, men are indeed animals, "modern masculinity" is fluid and therefore not as lethal as he might assume, and we can raise ourselves up higher if we accept these truths.





Run the Jewels - "Ooh LA LA" (Singles Going Steady)

Run the Jewels' "Ooh LA LA" may hit with old-school hip-hop swagger, but it also frustratingly affirms misogynistic bro-culture.


New Translation of Balzac's 'Lost Illusions' Captivates

More than just a tale of one man's fall, Balzac's Lost Illusions charts how literature becomes another commodity in a system that demands backroom deals, moral compromise, and connections.


Protomartyr - "Processed by the Boys" (Singles Going Steady)

Protomartyr's "Processed By the Boys" is a gripping spin on reality as we know it, and here, the revolution is being televised.


Go-Go's Bassist Kathy Valentine Is on the "Write" Track After a Rock-Hard Life

The '80s were a wild and crazy time also filled with troubles, heartbreak and disappointment for Go-Go's bass player-guitarist Kathy Valentine, who covers many of those moments in her intriguing dual project that she discusses in this freewheeling interview.


New Brain Trajectory: An Interview With Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree

Two guitarists, Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree make an album largely absent of guitar playing and enter into a bold new phase of their careers. "We want to take this wherever we can and be free of genre restraints," says Lee Ranaldo.


'Trans Power' Is a Celebration of Radical Power and Beauty

Juno Roche's Trans Power discusses trans identity not as a passageway between one of two linear destinations, but as a destination of its own.


Yves Tumor Soars With 'Heaven to a Tortured Mind'

On Heaven to a Tortured Mind, Yves Tumor relishes his shift to microphone caressing rock star. Here he steps out of his sonic chrysalis, dons some shiny black wings and soars.


Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras' tētēma Don't Hit the Mark on 'Necroscape'

tētēma's Necroscape has some highlights and some interesting ambiance, but ultimately it's a catalog of misses for Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras.


M. Ward Offers Comforting Escapism on 'Migration Stories'

Although M. Ward didn't plan the songs on Migration Stories for this pandemic, they're still capable of acting as a balm in these dark hours.


Parsonsfield Add Indie Pop to Their Folk on 'Happy Hour on the Floor'

Happy Hour on the Floor is a considerable departure from Parsonsfield's acclaimed rustic folk sound signaling their indie-pop orientation. Parsonsfield remind their audience to bestow gratitude and practice happiness: a truly welcomed exaltation.


JARV IS... - "House Music All Night Long" (Singles Going Steady)

"House Music All Night Long" is a song our inner, self-isolated freaks can jive to. JARV IS... cleverly captures how dazed and confused some of us may feel over the current pandemic, trapped in our homes.


All Kinds of Time: Adam Schlesinger's Pursuit of Pure, Peerless Pop

Adam Schlesinger was a poet laureate of pure pop music. There was never a melody too bright, a lyrical conceit too playfully dumb, or a vibe full of radiation that he would shy away from. His sudden passing from COVID-19 means one of the brightest stars in the power-pop universe has suddenly dimmed.


Folkie Eliza Gilkyson Turns Up the Heat on '2020'

Eliza Gilkyson aims to inspire the troops of resistance on her superb new album, 2020. The ten songs serve as a rallying cry for the long haul.


Human Impact Hit Home with a Seismic First Album From a Veteran Lineup

On their self-titled debut, Human Impact provide a soundtrack for this dislocated moment where both humanity and nature are crying out for relief.


Monophonics Are an Ardent Blast of True Rock 'n' Soul on 'It's Only Us'

The third time's the charm as Bay Area soul sextet Monophonics release their shiniest record yet in It's Only Us.


'Slay the Dragon' Is a Road Map of the GOP's Methods for Dividing and Conquering American Democracy

If a time traveler from the past wanted to learn how to subvert democracy for a few million bucks, gerrymandering documentary Slay the Dragon would be a superb guide.


Bobby Previte / Jamie Saft / Nels Cline: Music from the Early 21st Century

A power-trio of electric guitar, keyboards, and drums takes on the challenge of free improvisation—but using primarily elements of rock and electronica as strongly as the usual creative music or jazz. The result is focused.


Does Inclusivity Mean That Everyone Does the Same Thing?

What is the meaning of diversity in today's world? Russell Jacoby raises and addresses some pertinent questions in his latest work, On Diversity.

Collapse Expand Reviews
Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.